commentators as “soft law”, or as an evolving norm that needs to be taken into account when
assessing the existence of a binding rule. Not only are there significant difficulties as a
matter of methodology in determining whether a customary rule exists, but also it is
necessary to take into account the dynamic nature of international law and the place of
emerging principles.
The significance of evolving norms creates a particular difficulty when advising on
international human rights. Most States are party to the fundamental international human
rights documents and treaties such as the Universal Declaration on Human Rights,
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the Conventions on Genocide,
Torture, Sex Discrimination and Racial Discrimination. However, the more complex
provisions of multilateral human rights agreements over the last 20 years have not yet
attracted general adherence. For this reason, and while treaties will apply as between the
States parties, the principles they contain do not yet have the status of customary law. Such
treaty based evolving norms will not be binding on non-parties. Equally however, these
principles may well be evolving or crystallising into accepted principles of customary law.
Thus the task for the Council of Jurists will often be to advise in a highly fluid context in
which the technically ‘correct’ assessment of the asserted rule is that it does not yet have the
status of binding customary law. The consequence of such a ‘hard’ law approach is that
advice based upon it will fail to take into account evolving principles of probable future
force. A more robust and creative approach has been supported by the United Nations High
Commission for Human Rights. At the Seventh meeting of the APF, Mr Brian Burdekin of
the UNHCHR argued that an informed and creative judiciary could be willing to understand
the dynamic nature of international law and to take judicial notice of evolving principles.
A recent example has been provided by Australia’s High Court in the Minister for
Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v. Teoh ((1995) 183 CLR 273) (Teoh Case) in which the
majority of the Court found that there is a “legitimate expectation” that administrative
officials will inform themselves about treaty obligations accepted by Australia.
The
importance of this decision lies in the fact that officials should take into account treaties to
which Australia is a party even where Parliament has yet to provide a legislative means of
applying those principles in domestic law. The Teoh case is illustrative of a universal
phenomenon under which States sign and ratify human rights treaties but fail to implement
141
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление