those treaties fully or appropriately in domestic law. The potential role of a creative and
informed judiciary in taking notice of such treaties in the absence of implementing legislation
remains controversial however.
With these complexities in mind, the Council of Jurists might appropriately state both the
clear “hard’ law insofar as it exists in treaties and custom and then explain the evolving
principles or ‘soft’ law that are thought likely to create or stimulate new laws.
Evidences of custom
As a practical matter, advice as to the status of a customary rule will require documentation
of State practice through the following kinds of evidence.
•
Practices of international organs including the National Labour Organisation, United
Nations General Assembly and Security Council and specialised agencies. The legal
effect of a UN General Assembly resolution is highly controversial. For a resolution
to be evidence of custom, it will be necessary to show a strong adherence to the
asserted rule, including that of the most affected States (Texaco Case).
•
Jurisprudence of international courts and tribunals including the International Court of
Justice, arbitral tribunals, ad hoc war crimes tribunals, International Criminal Court,
mixed claims commissions, WTO’s Appellate Body and the International Tribunal for
the Law of the Sea
•
State legislation.
•
Judicial decisions of State courts, official State documents such as military, naval and
air-force manuals.
•
Acts or declarations by representatives of States, opinions of legal advisers.
•
Bilateral and regional treaties.
•
Decisions of international arbitral tribunals.
•
Decisions of other international courts such as the International Tribunal for Law of
the Sea, the World Trade Organization’s dispute body.
•
The findings and resolutions of mixed claims commissions.
•
Juristic works as a subsidiary means for determining the rules of law.
142
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление