can be demonstrated in the case of a State. The requirement that there be evidence of opinio
juris has led to much judicial and academic debate. It remains helpful, however, to use the
concept of opinio juris to distinguish custom from an act that is followed for reasons of
comity or courtesy. The court in West Rand Central Gold Mining Company v R [1905] 2 KB
391 at 407 held that opinio juris must be proved by satisfactory evidence that the alleged rule
“is of such a nature, and has been so widely and generally accepted, that it can hardly be
supposed that any civilised State would repudiate it”.
The International Court in the North Sea Continental Shelf Cases (ICJ 1969,3) argued that:
Not only must the acts concerned amount to a settled practice, but they must also be such, or
be carried out in such a way, as to be evidence of a belief that this practice is rendered
obligatory by the existence of a rule of law requiring it. The need for such a belief, ie the
existence of a subjective element, is implicit in the very notion of the opinio juris. The States
concerned must therefore feel that they are conforming to what amounts to a legal obligation.
Difficulties in demonstrating the subjective element have been recognised by subsequent
courts and, in practice, the emphasis has moved to objective evidence of consistent State
practice. The International Court adopted a more useful modern approach to custom in the
Nicaragua case [1986] ICJ 14:
The court does not consider that, for a rule to be established as customary, the corresponding
practice must be in absolutely rigorous conformity with the rule. In order to deduce the
existence of customary rules, the court deems it sufficient that the conduct of States should, in
general, be consistent with such rules, and that instances of State conduct inconsistent with a
given rule should generally have been treated as breaches of that rule, not as indications of the
recognition of a new rule.
While it remains necessary to satisfy the twin elements of State practice and opinio juris
when assessing the status of a purported customary rule, the courts today are more concerned
to document State activities as the best evidence of their express or implied consent to a new
obligation.
What are ‘soft’ and ‘hard’ international law?
An important issue of customary law arises where an emerging rule does not yet satisfy the
requirements for the creation of custom but is regarded as likely to do so over time. Such an
emerging rule is described as lex ferenda. Recognition of evolving law is considered by legal
140
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление