CHAPTER 3
INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS ON EVICTION AND RESETTLEMENT
It is essential at this juncture to recall the position taken by international law that forced
evictions are prima facie incompatible with core human rights standards. It follows
from the guarantees recognised in Chapter 2, particularly the security of tenure that is
an essential component of adequate housing, that occupants should be protected
from the effects of forced evictions. That is, as a general rule, government
programmes and practices which require the involuntary transfer of populations and
the demolition of residential premises will be prohibited. However, international law
nonetheless recognises the presence of forced evictions throughout the world, and
their legitimacy in limited circumstances. The nature of these circumstances, and the
manner in which forced evictions are to be conducted, are strictly controlled under
international law.
Unlike some standards based on ESC rights, those identified in this Chapter are not
targets or goals towards which governments should aspire, but benchmarks that must
be adhered to immediately in the context of eviction and resettlement policy or
practice. In addition to their use in this review to determine compliance with
international human rights law, the purpose of these standards is to assist other
independent eviction and human rights monitors to evaluate government activity in
this field.
3.1
Availability of Resources
Sources
Governments are generally allowed a generous measure of flexibility
in adhering to their obligations under the ICESCR, particularly
because the promotion of the associated human rights is often an
expensive exercise, requiring the availability and expenditure of
considerable resources. This consideration will almost never be
relevant in the context of forced evictions, which typically accompany
large government infrastructure projects or land sales with significant
fiscal ramifications of themselves. The obligation to implement and
enforce legislative protections for individuals, groups and
communities against the effects of forced evictions is therefore
immediate.
ICESCR, arts. 2.1;
11(1)
ICCPR, art. 17(1)
GC VII, para. 8
Basic Principles,
para. 23
13