PASTOR RAYMOND KOH
Admissibility of Evidence
73.
The Panel is not constrained or limited by the Evidence Act 1950 in the recepon
of evidence during the Public Inquiry. A flexible approach is taken whereby
evidence which is not usually admied in criminal and civil proceedings may be
received by the Public Inquiry. This is recognised by Secon 14(1)(a) and (d) of
the Act where it states the “The Commission shall, for the purposes of an inquiry
under this Act, have the power - (a) to procure and receive all such evidence,
wrien or oral, and to examine all such persons as witnesses, as the Commission
thinks necessary or desirable to procure or examine;” and “(d) to admit
notwithstanding any of the provisions of the Evidence Act 1950 [Act 56], any
evidence, whether wrien or oral, which may be inadmissible in civil or criminal
proceedings.
74.
This flexibility is in line with internaonal standards regarding human rights
inquiries in the following cases:
74.1.
In Bamaca-Velasquez v Guatemala 22 , the Inter-American Court of
Human Rights held:
“97. In an internaonal tribunal such as the Court, whose aim is
the protecon of human rights, the proceeding has its own
characteriscs that differenate it from the domesc process. The
former is less formal and more flexible than the laer, which does
not imply that it fails to ensure legal certainty and procedural
balance to the pares. This grants the Court a greater latude to
use logic and experience in evaluang the evidence rendered to it
on the pernent facts.
131. Taking this into account, the Court aributes a high
probave value to tesmonial evidence in proceedings of this
type, that is, in the context and circumstances of cases of forced
disappearance, with all the aendant difficules, when, owing to
the very nature of the crime, proof essenally takes the form of
indirect and circumstanal evidence."
74.2.
In Velasquez-Rodriguez v Honduras 23 , the Inter-American Court of
Human Rights held that direct evidence is not the only type of evidence
22
IACHR Series C No 70 ( Official Citaon) [2000] IACHR 7 (Other Reference) IHRL 1453 (IACHR 2000) (OUP reference);
IACHR Series C No 91 (Official Citaon) [2002] IACHR 1 (Other Reference ) IHRL 1474 (IACHR 2002) (OUP reference).
23
Inter-Am.Ct.H.R. (Ser. C) No. 4 (1988), Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACrtHR), 29 July 1988.
28
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление