The Children’s Commissioner had noted in its
2017 annual State of Care report that material
conditions in Secure units more generally
remained institutionalised:
‘In the secure units, even in care and
protection residences, are prison-like and
unwelcoming. They contain few furnishings
and young people are not allowed to take
personal belongings in with them.’
I repeat my observation that the prison-like
environment in Secure Care rooms, where
children and young people, often with
previous trauma, are separated from their
peers and where they need to sleep and
Secure Care room in a Youth Justice facility.
attend to bodily needs in the same space,
are degrading, harmful and, as previously
suggested, inappropriate for housing children
and young people.
It is my hope that many of these issues will be
addressed in the new, community-based Care
and Protection facilities.
There was some evidence of trauma
informed work with children and young
people in Secure rooms, but the good work
was hampered, in my view, by the very
traumatising nature of these rooms.
Secure Care unit corridor in a Youth Justice facility.
34
Evidence provided to us by Oranga Tamariki
and reports from the Office of the Children’s
Commissioner’s OPCAT inspections
demonstrate some work in both Youth Justice
and Care and Protection residences to work
with children and young people to better
understand their strengths and weaknesses
and identify their triggers. These are welcome
initiatives. However, the Daily Management
Plans which were previously used (and
highlighted as good practice in TOTB) were no
longer completed daily, replaced instead with
a one-page summary.