Part II NHRIs in action
Criteria related to the suitability of the topic for an inquiry
• Whether the core evidence can be given in public
• Whether witnesses can be identified and will be available
• Whether the basic data are available.
• Whether the Commission can protect and support vulnerable witnesses and their families
• Whether the topic may open the Commission to a risk of retaliation
3. ESTABLISHING THE INQUIRY
NHRIs hereby agree … to consider the practical functions they can fulfil in promoting enhanced
protection against corporate-related human rights abuse:
Examining the conditions of access to justice for all, including through conducting public
enquiries, with particular reference to indigent, vulnerable and marginalized groups, affected by
the business corporations and the private sector.
Edinburgh Declaration310
Choosing the issue for the public inquiry is one of the most important decisions that the NHRI will
make. While all human rights issues are important, the NHRI should seek to select an issue:
• that is objectively significant in the country, considering the numbers of people affected, the
severity of the violations or the widespread nature of the violations
• that has the potential to build broad, long-term public understanding and support for change
• where there is an active, engaged civil society that will collaborate with the inquiry, provide
information, contribute to hearings and advocate for the recommendations.
The inquiry should seek to break new ground. It should not cover issues that have been the subject of
previous inquiries, undertaken either by the NHRI or other bodies.
A public inquiry on the rights of migrant workers could canvass any one of a number of topics, such as
the human rights impact of migration laws and policies, including the administrative detention of migrants
in an irregular situation; the operation, regulation and workplace conditions of certain industries; or laws,
policies and practices that limit access to education, housing and health services for migrant workers
and members of their families.
While some issues may be apparent from reviewing its complaints data and monitoring activities, NHRIs
should consult directly with communities of migrant workers to better understand the issues
that have the greatest impact on their ability to live and work with dignity and safety. The feedback that
migrant workers and their representatives provide should be taken into account when the NHRI finalizes
the subject for its public inquiry and develops its terms of reference.
These consultations also provide an opportunity to explain to migrant workers what a national inquiry is,
how it will operate, what it will seek to achieve and how they can participate in the process.
For many migrant workers, a public inquiry may be their first and only opportunity to tell their stories and
seek a remedy for human rights violations they have experienced. However, some may feel intimidated
about taking part in a formal, “legal” process and some may face barriers around language and literacy.
310
Edinburgh Declaration; 10th International Conference of National Institutions for the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights;
Edinburgh, Scotland; 8–10 October 2010; Section B: Monitoring, Part II.
Chapter 9: Conducting public inquiries into systemic patterns of human rights violation | 125
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление