Promoting and Protecting the Rights of Migrant Workers The Role of National Human Rights Institutions
give evidence to the inquiry. Therefore, the NHRI should have the legal authority to conduct a full and
thorough investigation and collect all necessary evidence.
The likelihood of effectiveness
The NHRI must consider whether there is a realistic prospect that progress can be made to address
the human rights issues that the inquiry proposes to consider. The inquiry should be able to provide
recommendations that provide redress for past violations, as well as propose practical strategies to
prevent future violations. In coming to this assessment, NHRIs should take a broad and long-term
view of the situation. If resources and political will to implement the inquiry’s recommendations are not
present in the short-term, these may be forthcoming at a future time, especially if the NHRI is a strong
and consistent advocate on the issue and has the support of civil society organizations and other
stakeholders.
Table 9.1: Criteria for deciding whether to conduct a national human rights inquiry309
Developed by the Australian Human Rights Commission and the Uganda Human Rights Commission in
2000 and expanded at a workshop in Kampala, Uganda, in 2003.
Criteria related to the Commission as an institution
• Whether the Commission has the necessary public credibility (including independence)
• Whether the Commission is the appropriate body or the only body responsible for the subject matter
• Whether the Commission is able to manage public expectations
• Whether the Commission can accommodate a variety of interests and views on a topic
Criteria related to the significance of the topic
• Whether there are strong community stakeholders for the topic
• Whether requests have been received for the inquiry from the relevant sector
• Whether the topic is ground-breaking or has already been well-covered
• Whether the public agrees generally that the topic is a relevant one
• Whether the subject can sustain public interest
• Whether the topic would attract widespread public empathy or, alternatively, would be controversial
Criteria related to the Commission’s resources
• Whether any previous inquiries were successful or, if unsuccessful, whether the problems can be overcome
• Whether Commission resources are adequate (includes financial and human resources)
• Whether the Commission has the expertise or can obtain it
• Whether resources can be committed to evaluation and follow-up
• Whether the Commission could work in partnership with another body
Criteria relating to the potential effectiveness of an inquiry on this topic
• Whether other strategies would be as effective
• Whether the Commission will be able to come up with implementable recommendations – the report
should not be a mere academic treatise
• Whether it is likely that the inquiry’s recommendations will be implemented
309
Public Inquiry Planning Model Guidelines for Commonwealth Human Rights Commissions; Workshop for Commonwealth Human
Rights Commissions (sponsored by the British Council); Kampala, Uganda; 25–27 February 2003.
124 | Chapter 9: Conducting public inquiries into systemic patterns of human rights violation
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление