(c) What constitutes ‘proper
consideration’
The ACT and Victorian legislation do not specify
how the limitations clause interacts with the
obligation on public authorities, although this
question has been clarified through Victorian
caselaw. The limitations clause applies to the
substantive limb, meaning that an act will only
breach the positive duty when it cannot be
justified by reference to the full criteria in the
limitations clause. A slightly different approach
applies to the ‘proper consideration’ limb.
It has been established through Castles v
Secretary, Department of Justice,18 that the
‘proper consideration’ limb requires decision
makers to:
(1) Understand in general terms which of
the rights of the person affected by the
decision may be relevant and whether, and
if so how, those rights will be interfered
with by the decision; [Note that rights will
be ‘relevant’ if the proposed decision will
apparently limit such rights (that is, the
right is ‘engaged’), and rights should be
construed broadly in relation to this step]19
(2) seriously turn his or her mind to the
possible impact of the decision on a
person’s human rights and the implications
thereof for the affected person;
(3) identify the countervailing interests or
obligations; and
(4) balance competing private and
public interests as part of the exercise of
justification.20
Dr Bruce Chen comments that ‘these elements
appear to draw on some, but not all, of the
factors in the Victorian Charter’s general
limitations clause, and only in a broad sense’.21
In Castles v Secretary to the Department of
Justice, Emerton J elaborated that:
144
proper consideration of human rights
should not be a sophisticated legal
exercise. Proper consideration need
not involve formally identifying the
‘correct’ rights or explaining their
content by reference to legal principles
or jurisprudence … There is no formula
for such an exercise, and it should not be
scrutinised over-zealously by the courts.22
Although not necessarily requiring full formal
consideration of the limitation criteria to meet
the ‘proper consideration’ obligation, the
Victorian Charter still sets ‘a high bar’.23
Courts have stated that ‘completing a checklist’
or ‘merely invok[ing] the Charter like a mantra’
will not meet the required standard.24 The word
‘proper’ implies that the procedural limb of
s 38(1) is more stringent than the traditional
judicial review requirement of those involved
in public administration to take into account
relevant considerations.25 The standard of
consideration required will ‘differ depending
on the circumstances, including the identity of
the decision maker, the rights affected, and the
vulnerability of the rights-holders’.26
In the ACT, a similar approach has been adopted
by courts with respect to the application of the
procedural limb of the positive duty.27
In Queensland, s 58(5) of the Human Rights Act
states that the criteria for ‘proper consideration’
in decision making includes consideration of
whether the decision would be ‘compatible’
with human rights, which is defined as involving
the application of the full limitations clause.28
The Queensland Human Rights Act therefore
appears to diverge from the approach taken
in Victorian and ACT caselaw by explicitly
linking the full limitations test to the ‘proper
consideration’ limb, although this has not been
tested in case law to date.
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление