Limitations clause
The Commission’s proposal for criteria in
a limitations clause is as follows.
When deciding whether a limit is reasonable and
justifiable, the following factors are relevant:
• whether the limitation is in pursuit of
a legitimate purpose
• the relationship between the limitation
and its purpose, including whether the
limitation is necessary to achieve the
legitimate purpose, and whether it adopts
a means rationally connected to achieving
that purpose
The Commission proposes adopting the two
limbs of the positive duty for the federal
positive duty. The Commission also proposes
incorporating a procedural obligation to engage
in participation processes within the ‘proper
consideration’ limb where the ‘participation
duty’ arises in relation to a particular right.
The participation duty is discussed in chapter
7. This limb would therefore also encompass
a requirement to facilitate participation
with respect to decisions that directly or
disproportionately affect the rights of First
Nations peoples, children and persons with
disability; or otherwise justify a decision not
to facilitate participation by reference to the
limitations clause.
These obligations should not apply to federal
public authorities if ‘the public authority could
not reasonably have acted differently or made
a different decision’ in light of its empowering
legislation (as at the state level).16
• the extent of the interference with the
human right
• whether there are any less restrictive and
reasonably available means to achieve the
purpose
• whether there are safeguards or controls
over the means adopted to achieve the
purpose.
Additionally, the limitations clause would
prescribe that absolute rights such as freedom
from torture and freedom from forced work
must not be subject to any limitations.
(b) Cumulative approach
In Victoria, the two (procedural and substantive)
limbs have been interpreted as ‘cumulative’ in
nature. This means that public authorities must
give proper consideration to rights engaged,
and to reach a decision that is substantively
compatible with human rights. For example, in
Certain Children (No 2), it was held that even if
the decision maker’s interference with rights was
demonstrably justified, the failure to give proper
consideration to Charter rights in the decisionmaking process meant that the decision maker
acted unlawfully.17 This approach is logically
coherent in light of the distinct importance of
procedural obligations to ensuring human rights
compliance overall. The Commission therefore
proposes making it clear in the text of the
Human Rights Act that both procedural and
substantive limbs are required for human rights
compliance.
FREE AND EQUAL A Human Rights Act for Australia 2022
143
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление