60
Chasing the Wind: Assessing Philippine Democracy, Second Edition
seat cap, a clear violation of the principle of proportional representation which
is recognized as one of the “four inviolable parameters of the Philippine party
list system”. What are the effects of these rules on interest representation and
party formation?
From the point of view of representation, it appears that a wider set of
interests are indeed represented in the PL system but this practice also
magnies the problem of too many particularistic and narrow interests being
represented with no established mechanism for aggregating such interests. An
examination of the parties running under the PL system reveals a bewildering
array of organizations representing diverse interests including mainly ethnic
and religious concerns and all kinds of y-by-night dummy organizations
opportunistically set up by powerful vested interests to win congressional
seats. In fact, these narrow interest groups undermine the legitimacy of the
truly programmatic parties running under this list which could gain more seats
and exert a stronger impact on the legislative process in a truly proportional
system of voting without seat caps.
Thus, the current PL system has actually aggravated the problem of
multipartism in presidential systems which could accentuate “immobilism” in
the relationship between the executive and legislature or result in “purely
opportunistic negotiated deals, wheeling and dealing, legislative log-rolling,
etc.”(Sartori 1997). In short, the PL system as it has actually been implemented
has resulted in a false sense of democratic representation which may in fact
further strengthen presidential powers at the expense of the legislature. If a PL
system with proportional representation (PR) is to be combined with
presidentialism, already a problem by itself, it would be better to abide by the
strict logic of the PR system of election by doing away with the seat caps but
retaining a reasonable minimum winning threshold to control the excessive
party fragmentation at work in the present system. Side by side with these
reforms, it is also worthwhile looking into the possibility of increasing the seats
allocated for the party list system to help balance the entrenched oligarchic
power of the dominant political families in Congress. These rules would be an
incentive for the programmatic parties representing broader interests as they
can win more seats proportional to their actual strength while discouraging
those identied with the narrowest interests and constituencies.
Political Variables and Socio-Economic Outcomes
Political leadership is a crucial factor in deciding concrete developmental
outcomes locally and nationally. However, it is also the case that such
leadership whether exercised through political families or non-traditional ones
always needs to grapple with concrete historical and political constraints and
its outcomes are also ltered through various institutions and practices.
Moreover, other variables such as the initial conditions of growth and the
impact of natural resources and geography also play important roles in
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление