Promoting and Protecting the Rights of Migrant Workers The Role of National Human Rights Institutions
In addition, NHRIs should monitor the forced deportation of migrants to ensure their safety, dignity and
protection, especially in instances where an individual is potentially being deported to country where he
or she is at risk of torture or ill-treatment.
The Association for the Prevention of Torture notes that:
Forced deportation is a moment where detainees are particularly vulnerable and exposed to the
risk of ill-treatment and torture. There is serious ongoing human rights concern worldwide where
refoulement, excessive use of force and even loss of life are increasingly common.282
NHRIs that have been designated as an NPM under the OPCAT have a particular responsibility in this regard.
NHRIs can also make recommendations to the Government that forced deportation only be used as a
last resort, that the State respect the fundamental principle of “non-refoulement” and that any deportation
only proceed “following a fair and efficient process which guarantees that all the legal safeguards have
been applied”.283
3. MONITORING PLACES OF DETENTION
NHRIs should monitor their Governments’ obligation to respect, protect and fulfil the rights of all
people in detention, especially vulnerable or marginalised groups.
Nairobi Declaration284
Independent monitoring of places of detention is a crucial element of a comprehensive programme of
action that NHRIs can take to promote and protect the rights of migrants deprived of their liberty.
Good practice has shown that the mere fact that independent bodies can enter places of detention, at
any time, has a strong deterrent effect and sheds light on conditions and treatment in detention. It can
also be instrumental in pressing and assisting the relevant authorities to address and improve conditions
of detention and the treatment of detainees.285
Monitoring work can be undertaken when NHRIs investigate individual complaints or allegations of
ill-treatment. It can also form part of a preventive strategy to improve conditions of detention and the
treatment of detainees.
Some NHRIs have established a regular programme of visits to immigration detention facilities and other
places of detention where migrants are held.
As noted previously, some NHRIs have been designated as their country’s NPM and have specific
authority to conduct regular and unannounced “preventive” visits to all places of detention in the country.
There are certain powers that NHRIs require in order to effectively undertake preventive monitoring of
detention facilities. These powers, set out in the OPCAT, include:
• access to all types of places where persons are deprived of their liberty
• access to all facilities within the place of detention
• access to all necessary records and information
• access to all persons deprived of their liberty and to any other person
• liberty to choose the persons to interview and the location where the interview is carried out
• the ability to interview detainees in private.
282
National Preventive Mechanisms: Monitoring the Forced Deportation Flights of Migrants; OPCAT Briefing Series; Association for
the Prevention of Torture; 2012; p. 1.
283
Ibid; p. 2.
284
Nairobi Declaration; 9th International Conference of National Institutions for the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights;
Nairobi, Kenya; 21–24 October 2008; para. 42.
285
Protecting asylum-seekers, refugees and migrants in detention; APT Position Paper; Association for the Prevention of Torture; 2012.
112 | Chapter 8: Protecting the rights of migrants in detention
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents