Part II NHRIs in action
health of detainees. This can be compounded by overcrowding, poor physical conditions of detention
and limited access to appropriate health services.
NHRIs can research and advocate for alternative approaches to the administrative detention of refugees,
asylum seekers and migrants in an irregular situation, “such as supervised release, release on bail,
designated residence or regular reporting to authorities”.279
Drawing on international research and case studies from different parts of the globe, the International
Detention Coalition has identified a range of benefits in limiting the application of detention and prioritizing
community-based management options, including that:
• the costs of community-based management options are less than detention options
• rates of voluntary return and independent departure are increased
• the possibility of wrongful detention and litigation is reduced
• overcrowding of detention facilities and the use of long-term detention are reduced
• the health and welfare of migrants is improved.280
In addition, community-based management options can assist States in their duty to respect, protect
and fulfil the human rights of migrants.281
CASE STUDY
The Australian Human Rights Commission regularly monitors all immigration
detention centres in the country. Over the last decade, the Commission’s
reports have highlighted the serious impact that prolonged and indefinite
detention has on the mental health of detainees, particularly those who have
experienced torture and trauma.
These concerns escalated in 2010–11, with evidence of the deteriorating
mental health of many detainees. This included high rates of self-harm, a
number of suicides and serious unrest in immigration detention facilities.
The Commission has consistently advocated for the use of communitybased alternatives, which are “cheaper, more effective and more humane
than holding asylum seekers and refugees in closed detention facilities
for extended periods. This approach is also consistent with Australia’s
international human rights obligations.”281
In June 2011, the Australian Government transferred a significant number of
families and unaccompanied children from immigration detention facilities
to community-based detention.
While welcoming the change in policy, the Commission noted that more
than 4,500 asylum seekers and refugees were still held in immigration
detention facilities across Australia. It continued to recommend that
immigration detention be used as a last resort and for the shortest
practicable time.
279
Report of the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention; UN Human Rights Council; A/HRC/7/4; p. 25.
280
There are Alternatives: A Handbook for Preventing Unnecessary Immigration Detention; International Detention Coalition; 2011;
p. 9.
281
Annual Report 2010–11; Australian Human Rights Commission; 2011; p. 36.
Chapter 8: Protecting the rights of migrants in detention | 111
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents