Part II NHRIs in action • ensuring migrant children held in detention can continue their education • ensuring detainees can observe their cultural and religious practices. NHRIs should also promote reforms to ensure effective safeguards are in place to prevent torture and illtreatment, including “prompt access to a lawyer, the ability to challenge detention, a medical examination by an independent physician and the ability to contact family or consular representatives”.295 NHRIs “should work with their Government to ensure that those in detention have the opportunity to complain about violations of their rights, including to the NHRI (for example through face-to-face complaints, complaint boxes or on-site human rights counselling services), and, where a violation is found, that detainees have access to a remedy and compensation”.296 Recommendations for the reform of detention policies and procedures can be directed to the authorities of specific facilities. However, through its monitoring activities, the NHRI may identify systemic issues and develop recommendations for reform across all detention facilities. NHRIs should engage directly with the relevant ministries or authorities to advocate for the adoption of necessary reforms. In addition, these recommendations could be included in thematic or annual reports prepared by the NHRI for the parliament. 3.3. Investigating complaints of torture, ill-treatment or human rights violations NHRIs should promptly investigate and document any allegations of human rights violations involving detainees that are brought to their attention. These allegations may come to the NHRI from the detainee, a friend or relative of a detainee or during the course of its monitoring work. NHRIs should seek to collect all available evidence in relation to the complaint, beginning with an interview with the victim. This should be conducted in private, although an interpreter may also be required to be present. Following the interview, it is necessary to cross-check the information collected and to assess the reliability of the allegations made.297 To help make this assessment, it is important to consider: • if the testimony is convincing and internally consistent • if the testimony corresponds to known patterns of human rights violations or is consistent with information from other independent sources • if other testimonies, such as those from detainees in the same facility, corroborate the victim’s statement • other physical, medical or administrative evidence corroborates the victim’s statement • the response to the allegations provided by detaining authority.298 All information collected during the investigation should be stored securely. As an additional precaution, NHRIs should consider identifying files by numbers, rather than by names, with the corresponding list of names filed separately from the substantive records.299 295 Protecting asylum-seekers, refugees and migrants in detention; APT Position Paper; Association for the Prevention of Torture; 2012; p. 2. 296 Nairobi Declaration; 9th International Conference of National Institutions for the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights; Nairobi, Kenya; 21–24 October 2008; para. 41. 297 In relation to allegations of torture, complete accuracy is seldom expected of torture victims. See Kisoki v. Sweden, Committee against Torture, Communication 41/1996, views adopted on 8 May 1996. 298 Preventing Torture: An Operational Guide for National Human Rights Institutions; Asia Pacific Forum of National Human Rights Institutions, Association for the Prevention of Torture and the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights; 2010; p. 41. 299 Ibid; p. 37. Chapter 8: Protecting the rights of migrants in detention | 115

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents