Promoting and Protecting the Rights of Migrant Workers The Role of National Human Rights Institutions
… a physician or qualified health professional as their participation is necessary to assess the
particular sensitive health issues. They should also consider hiring interpreters when relevant to
conduct private interviews with migrants in detention.291
Furthermore, it is critical that all members of the monitoring team respect the confidentiality of information
provided by detainees during private interviews. This includes interpreters292 who may be required to
assist members of the visiting team to conduct interviews with migrants. No information should be
released without the direct and informed consent of the detainee.293
Following the visit, the NHRI should prepare a short visit report for the detaining authority, which identifies
particular areas of concern, an analysis of the problems and practical recommendations that can be
implemented by the detaining authority.
The report forms part of an ongoing and cooperative dialogue with the detaining authority, based on the
overall goal of delivering measurable improvements over time in relation to the treatment of detainees
and the conditions of detention.
3.2. Reforming detention policies and procedures
Where migrants, asylum seekers and refugees are deprived of their liberty, international law places
specific obligations on States to safeguard their rights and dignity.
States must ensure that they are held in appropriate places of detention, that the conditions of detention
are acceptable and they have access to appropriate social and medical services. In addition, detainees
must also be protected from violence.294
However, the reality for many migrants, asylum seekers and refugees is that they are often held for
extended periods of time in overcrowded facilities, in poor conditions, with limited access to appropriate
health services and little or no access to asylum procedures.
Under international human rights law, detaining migrants for extended periods in locations such as
prisons or police holding cells would generally be considered inappropriate and has the potential to lead
to human rights violations that can amount to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment.
Based on their monitoring function, NHRIs can make specific recommendations to reform detention
policies and procedures to comply with international norms and to reflect the non-criminal status and
needs of asylum seekers, refugees and migrants in an irregular situation.
In addition, the needs of vulnerable groups of migrants should be considered and appropriate safeguards
put in place to ensure their safety and protection while in detention, including children, women, older
people, people with disabilities, victims of trafficking and survivors of torture.
NHRIs can use their advisory mandate to recommend reforms that promote and protect the rights,
safety, dignity and well-being of detainees, including:
• separating migrants from convicted criminals, migrant women from unrelated men, and migrant
children from unrelated adults
• addressing conditions of detention which amount to ill-treatment of detainees, including
overcrowding, inadequate food, poor sanitation, poor ventilation and poor heating
• providing appropriate medical care and support to meet the individual health needs of detainees
291
Protecting asylum-seekers, refugees and migrants in detention; APT Position Paper; Association for the Prevention of Torture;
2012; p. 2.
292
Detention Monitoring Briefing No. 3: Using Interpreters in Detention Monitoring; Association for the Prevention of Torture; 2009.
293
Specific information about interviewing people in places of detention is provided in Chapter 5 of Preventing Torture: An Operational
Guide for National Human Rights Institutions; Asia Pacific Forum of National Human Rights Institutions, Association for the
Prevention of Torture and the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights; 2010.
294
Migration and International Human Rights Law; Practitioner’s Guide No. 6; International Commission of Jurists; 2011; p. 164.
114 | Chapter 8: Protecting the rights of migrants in detention
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents