Chapter-VI
Judicial Control of Abuse of Investigatory and
Custodial Power
The police and other custodial institutions are conferred extensive and wide
powers to effectively investigate and exercise diverse kinds of restrants over the
body or property of the accused persons. However, often the judiciary is required
to adjudicate on the issues of abuse of aforesaid powers and make appropriate
restorative decisions. The situations leading to abuse of investigatory or custodial
powers relate mainly to instances of torture in the course of detention, arbitrary and
excessive detention, sexual abuse in custody, death in custody, extra-judicial
executions, etc. In the recent times, the problem of abuse of powers in the course of
extra- ordinary law and order situations and collusive disappearances and missing
persons/children has appeared as a new form of abuse of powers by the state
functionaries. Though there are large number of apex court rulings that aim at
laying down strict standards of exercise of executive powers, but judiciary at the
lower levels still requires explicit enunciation of such standard setting norms of
which the notable ones are given in the following tables:
Box-35
The court of the Judicial Magistrate/Metropolitan Magistrate shall:
S.176 (1A) Cr.P.C.
1.
Ensure that in case of death / disappearance
of a person from the police/judicial custody,
or in the case of rape on any woman while in
police/judicial custody, an enquiry is held by
a Judicial Magistrate/Metropolitan
Magistrate, within whose local jurisdiction the
offence has been committed, in addition to
the enquiry/ investigation held by the police.
2.
Ensure that the Magistrate holding such an
enquiry shall record all the evidences
collected during such enquiry required in to
the circumstances of the case.
53