66
Maranga Mai!
it. During another hui, the document was shredded
in front of officials. East Coast leaders presented a
gift of blankets to officials symbolising the inequity
of colonial-settler land dealings. Tame Iti found the
moral high ground atop a ladder in Ōpōtiki speaking
down to officials. He also opened a Tūhoe Embassy
outside Ruātoki and issued trespass and eviction
notices to those living on lands confiscated from
the Mataatua tribes and warned that ‘Trespassers
would be eaten’. At Ōwae marae in Waitara, three
hundred mainly young protesters sat motionless
wrapped in grey blankets in silent disapproval
echoing the dignified display of their ancestors when
Parihaka was sacked in 1881. Wira Gardiner who led
consultations on behalf of the Crown later lamented
his role promoting a package to Māori he agreed was
unfair (Walker, 2004, pp. 303-304).
Individual and collective acts of indignation and
dissent rippled across the country. The statue of
former premier John Ballance was decapitated
in Whanganui, Mike Smith chain-sawed the lone
pine on One Tree Hill, Benjamin Nathan hammered
the America’s Cup, and a Colin McCahon painting
was removed from the Lake Waikaremoana Visitor
Centre. Central to this resistance were a series of land
occupations at Whanganui’s Pākaitore or Moutoa
Gardens (twice), led by Ken Mair (Te Ahi Kaa protest
group), Niko Tangaroa and Tariana Tūria. Land
occupations included Takahue school in Northland
(leading to its destruction by fire) and others in
New Plymouth, Whakarewarewa, Huntly, Waikato
University, Kaikohe, Helensville, Ōtorohanga, Pātea
and Tāmaki Girls College in Auckland. The Pākaitore
occupation lasted 79 days. In an act of overt racism,
a judge imprisoned Ken Mair, for praying in Court
(Gifford, 1995, 1996).
Despite universal rejection from Māori, the
government formalised the Fiscal Envelope in a
new Office of Treaty Settlements (OTS). Officially
abandoned in 1996, in practice, the Envelope
remained the guideline against which all settlements
were measured, at least until the Central North Island
Forestry Settlement in 2008.
In addition to inadequate compensation, a main
weakness in the Envelope was how index values
allotted to settlements were manipulated to reduce
compensation. Landcorp New Zealand held lands,
reserved for settlement, in land banks which were
indexed to early 1990s Treaty settlement land
values. When the value of land parcels began
exceeding indexes during the late 1990s property
boom, Land Corp began selling them. This led to
the 2007 Whenuakite (Coromandel) and Rangiputa
(Muriwhenua) land occupations, which coincided
with complaints to the Waitangi Tribunal about OTS
methods. The settling of land claims in Auckland and
Te Arawa left some hapū groups out of the process, so
that OTS could meet Crown deadlines. The policy was
revised in 2007. In the north, Ngāti Kahu led several
campaigns protesting the small percentage value
of settlements compared to losses. In 2009, protest
leaders, Wikitana and John Junior Popata accosted
Prime Minister John Key at Te Tī marae on these
issue (Sunday Star Times, 18 March 2007; Northern
Advocate, 22 March 2007; Waitangi Tribunal, 2007).
Gendered protest (1998 to 2000)
White supremacist racism has different gender
dynamics. As Aotearoa entered the new millennium,
protests for Treaty justice evolved to include equal
rights under Article Three of the Treaty, the doctrine
of cultural equality and principles embedded within
international human rights instruments. In 1998,
Titewhai Harawira objected to Opposition Leader
Minister Helen Clark speaking during a pōwhiri at
Te Tī marae. Ms Harawira argued that if Māori
women could not speak from the paepae, then Ms
Clark should not do so either. Ms Clark’s view was
that Prime Minister Jenny Shipley had spoken on the
marae. Māori responded that this was after and not
during the pōwhiri. Labour and National reactions
were in marked contrast. The Crown returned official
ceremonies to Waitangi in 1999 and Ms Harawira
and Prime Minister Shipley walked arm-in-arm onto
Te Tī marae. Later that year, Ms Clark regained the
treasury benches but refused to return to Waitangi in
2000 shifting official observances back to Wellington
for the next two years.
Cultural rights (2002)
Two occupations in 2002 made stands on cultural
rights. In 2002, northern Māori objected to a proposal
to build a new prison at Ngāwhā Springs in Northland
after the Crown had prevailed upon the Northland