65
Human Rights Commission
With Queen Elizabeth II attending, Waitangi Day was
a gala occasion drawing thousands of spectators.
Protesters organised by Te Kawariki, a new northern
vanguard, were present but not with the numbers
of the early-1980s. Anglican Bishop of Aotearoa,
Whakahuihui Vercoe, chosen to perform the blessing
because of his conservative reputation, surprised
officials and protesters alike, with a speech that
encapsulated all there was to say about the Treaty.
Met by the jeers and chants of the protesters clustered
behind a police cordon, Bishop Vercoe stood to speak:
One hundred and fifty years ago, a compact
was signed, a covenant was made between two
people. But since the signing of that treaty, you,
our partners have marginalized us. You have not
honoured the Treaty. The language of this land is
yours; the custom is yours, the media by which we
tell the world who we are, are yours.
What I have come here for is to renew the ties that
made us a nation in 1840. I don’t want to debate
the Treaty; I don’t want to renegotiate the Treaty.
I want the Treaty to stand firmly as the unity, the
means by which we are made one nation. The
Treaty is what we are celebrating. It is what we are
trying to establish so that my tino-rangatiratanga
is the same as your Kāwanatanga.
And so, I have come to Waitangi to cry for the
promises that you made and for the expectations
our tūpuna (ancestors) had 150 years ago. And so,
I conclude, as I remember the songs of our land,
as I remember the history of our land, I weep here
on the shores of the Bay of Islands (New Zealand
Herald, 7 February 1990).
When he finished both protesters and officials
were silent.
The Fiscal Envelope (1994)
Encouraged by the relative success of the
sesquicentennial, official celebrations remained at
Waitangi. An uneasy peace reigned. Meanwhile,
tensions were building. Tribes were unhappy with the
way the Crown had finalised the Sealord’s Fisheries
Deal (New Zealand Herald, 7 February 1990). The
first Treaty settlements over land losses at Ōrākei and
Waiheke Island were significantly smaller than the
losses and the strict limits on its resources restrained
the Waitangi Tribunal (Kelsey, 1990, p. 127).
The bubble burst in 1994, with the release of Crown
Proposals for the Settlement of Treaty of Waitangi
Claims. Colloquially termed the ‘Fiscal Envelope’, the
proposals planned to settle all known and unknown
Treaty claims for $1 billion. Apart from Tainui, who
were signing the first settlement under the new
proposals, Māori opposition was universal, the
proposed fiscal limit represented a paltry percentage
of Māori losses since 1840.
Te Kawau Mārō, a group of Auckland Māori students
were representative of an emerging generation
of indigenous protesters steeped in the theory of
decolonisation, anti-racism, and wanting selfdetermination for Māori. They coordinated protests
at the University of Auckland, outside the High
Court, the Asian Development Conference, and the
Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting,
which included making an impromptu presentation of
a rangatiratanga flag to Nelson Mandela.
In January 1995, 1,000 delegates to the Hīrangi Hui
of the newly formed and Māori funded Tā Hepi Te
Heuheu-led Māori Congress, unanimously opposed
the ‘Fiscal Envelope’ as racist and unjust. The National
government rejected an offer to meet, describing
the Congress as ‘misguided’. Tensions boiled over
at Waitangi. Tame Iti stomped on the New Zealand
flag, showed his bottom, and spat with aplomb in the
direction of the Governor-General and Prime Minister
Jim Bolger. Police arrested a young Māori woman for
throwing a t-shirt to the Queen. Hinewhare Harawira
was jailed for spitting at the Queen. Hone Harawira
and government official Wira Gardiner wrestled
across the marae. Protest flags were hoisted on the
Treaty House grounds. The protesters had won an
emphatic victory and the National government, like
Labour a decade earlier, moved official ceremonies
to Government House for the next three years (Walker,
2004, pp. 303-304).
The Crown pressed forward with the Fiscal Envelope
holding a series of consultation hui around the
country. Māori considered the policy racist and
vehemently rejected the proposal. Northern tribes
sent a clear message to the Crown cancelling the hui
at Mangamuka. At Tauranga, a challenging warrior
threw down a copy of the proposal and stomped on