(d) Participation test
Public authorities would also be required to
consider whether consultation or other forms
of participation are necessary in light of the
participation duty. This would form part of the
‘proper consideration’ limb of the positive duty.
The participation duty is discussed in chapter
7. The participation duty would require public
authorities to facilitate the participation of First
Nations peoples, children and persons with
disability in relation to decisions that directly or
disproportionately affect their rights. It would
operate as a cross-cutting duty, meaning it
would be relevant to the fulfilment of all the
rights in the Human Rights Act.
When a case is brought alleging a breach of a
specific right protected by the Human Rights
Act, a failure to enable participation as part of
the decision-making process may demonstrate
that there has been a failure to give proper
consideration to that right, which would be a
breach of the positive duty to uphold the right
in question. The ability to raise the participation
duty will therefore be linked to a specific
decision engaging specific protected rights,
as well as meeting standing requirements in
accordance with the Human Rights Act. There
will be no distinct cause of action available
based on failure to enable participation.
When determining how to apply the
participation duty in particular circumstances,
public authorities, and courts assessing
the compliance of public authorities with
the duty, can draw on the rights in relevant
treaties, as well as procedural ‘participation
guidelines’ listed in chapter 7 section 7.5(b). The
limitations criteria would also be relevant to this
assessment, taking into account, for example,
urgency.
The participation duty would be considered as
one factor relevant to the ‘proper consideration’
limb of the positive duty on public authorities
– and would only arise where the participation
duty is engaged with respect to a particular
right.
146
6.3 Failure to comply with
the duty
If a public authority does not comply with the
positive duty, a person can make a complaint or
bring a claim against them for breach of human
rights, and may seek remedies for the breach.
This is discussed in chapter 11.
6.4 Scope of duty on public
authorities
(a) Defining public authorities
The contracting by government authorities with
the private sector to provide public services
has become a prevalent fixture of the operation
of government in Australia. It is essential
that the same standards apply to private
bodies delivering public services that apply
to government institutions. Access to human
rights protections should not depend on the
method of service delivery. Stakeholders such
as the Australian Lawyers Alliance emphasised
that the positive duty should comprehensively
apply to entities performing public functions,
to avoid government ‘contracting out’ of
human rights obligations.36 This is particularly
important in relation to contracting entities
that provide essential services to vulnerable
people. Recent inquiries, such as the Disability
Royal Commission and the Royal Commission
into Aged Care Quality and Safety, have shown
the serious consequences of private services
not being held accountable to human rights
standards.37
The definition of ‘public authorities’ must
therefore encompass private businesses, nongovernment organisations and contractors
performing public functions.38 The definition
should be flexible enough to accommodate
changes to governance arrangements and clear
enough to provide certainty as to who must
comply with a Human Rights Act.39 Certainty
is necessary for organisations as they will need
to take steps to ensure they are compliant, and
for individuals affected by the actions of public
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات