In consultations, Queensland stakeholders
observed that while it is useful to have a
single test for both limbs of the duty, in some
circumstances it will not be appropriate to
require a detailed process of consideration
before acting. Particularly in frontline and/or
emergency decision making it may be difficult
to implement the full set of criteria within the
limitations test – for example, while making
triaging decisions in a hospital. It was observed
that something in the nature of a proportionality
test is required, but it may not be practical to
prescribe the application of the full limitations
clause in all decision-making scenarios.29
To achieve the most workable approach,
it was suggested in consultations that the
Victorian (and ACT) approach is preferred.
The Commission agrees with this analysis
and prefers the approach that the limitations
test apply in full to the ‘acting compatibly’
limb, while a less formal test be applied to the
procedural requirement, recognising the realities
of operational decision making and situational
exigencies faced by public authorities. The
Commission would be well-placed to develop
general and specific guidance for public
authorities about how all limbs of the positive
duty are to be applied in practice.
The Commission also notes that, outside of
Human Rights Act caselaw, there are a number
of Federal Court cases that have articulated the
standard of ‘consideration’ that decision makers
must have regarding relevant matters when
making administrative decisions. These cases
have largely arisen in the migration context, and
provide insight that may also inform the ‘proper
consideration’ limb of a federal Human Rights
Act.
Relevantly, Federal Courts have found that there
is a need for an ‘active intellectual process’
and the giving of ‘proper, genuine and realistic
consideration’ to relevant matters.30 Many of the
cases in the Federal Court express frustration
about the use of formulaic expressions by
Ministers.31 In Hands v Minister for Immigration
and Border Protection,32 for example, the Full
Federal Court held that:
where decisions might have devastating
consequences visited upon people, the
obligation of real consideration of the
circumstances of the people affected
must be approached confronting what
is being done to people. This obligation
and the expression of its performance
is not a place for decisional checklists
or formulaic expression. Mechanical
formulaic expression and pre-digested
shorthand expressions may hide a lack of
the necessary reflection upon the whole
consideration of the human consequences
involved. Genuine consideration of the
human consequences demands honest
confrontation of what is being done to
people.33
A number of these cases were referenced in
the 2022 High Court decision of Plaintiff M12021 v Minister for Home Affairs.34 However it
is worth noting that Kiefel CJ, Keane, Gordon
and Steward JJ clarified that the requirements
for ‘proper, genuine and realistic’ consideration
‘must be understood in its proper context’ —
specifically the court must not ‘substitute its
decision for that of an administrative decision
maker’.35 This indicates that courts should
respect the distinction between merits review
and judicial review, and avoid using this kind
of analysis to substitute their own preferred
decision.
FREE AND EQUAL A Human Rights Act for Australia 2022
145
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات