In September 2022, the Inquiry issued a public call
asking those with experience of the emergency
housing system to contact us and share their
stories, experiences, and perspectives. People
could email or phone us, and we also launched a
dedicated website where people could share their
stories. In some cases, we were able to sit down
face to face or engage directly over Zoom/Teams.
“We’ve been in emergency for nearly four
years. I live in a small studio, with a bar fridge,
malfunctioning freezer, one chair and table
and share a bed with my kids. We look like
hoarders, our bathroom is our storage because
one wardrobe fits next to nothing. Our room
has no ventilation whatsoever, so it’s either
really hot or really cold.” [Resident in emergency
accommodation]
We heard from those currently in the system,
those who have moved through it into longer-term
housing, from service providers and advocates,
and from people outside the system – family
members, friends, people living near emergency
housing, and others.
What we have heard overall is distressing. In
many respects it was clear that, despite its good
intent, the system had failed those who most
needed help. Instead of supporting people through
housing insecurity and back into sustainable
solutions, emergency accommodation and
transitional housing can create or exacerbate
problems and trauma that continue to affect
people long after they have left the system.
Quality, conditions, and access to essential
facilities
We heard from existing and former residents
about the poor habitability of both emergency
accommodation and transitional housing, and the
lack of access to essential facilities such as cooking
and laundry.
“[My family members] were moved to a motel
which was filthy and had no cooking facilities
in the room … their next room fortunately had
cooking facilities, but the condition was absolutely
disgusting with holes in the walls, vomit and
food on the walls, mouldy curtains which affects
[child’s] asthma. The door doesn’t lock properly
and several times has had to be left unlocked. This
has all been reported several times and to date
nothing has been repaired.” [Family member of
resident in emergency accommodation]
“The conditions of the property were bad. The
place was full of cockroaches, she experienced
cockroaches crawling across her face in her
room and in the kitchen.” [Former resident of
emergency accommodation]
Multiple residents raised concerns about the
condition of their housing causing health issues,
especially for their children.
“My kids get sick nearly every second week. My
eldest [child] has been in hospital twice due to our
hotel situation and now has asthma.” [Resident in
emergency accommodation]
We heard a lot about the inadequacy of motelbased emergency accommodation. Clear themes
included:
•
Lack of basic facilities. Some motel
accommodation did not include even the
most basic cooking facilities in the room,
while others provided facilities fundamentally
inappropriate for the length of stay (e.g. bar
fridges, a single hot plate).
•
Extremely poor quality, sometimes to the
extent that it created serious health or safety
issues for residents. Damage caused by
previous residents was often not fixed, and
some people were given rooms that had not
been adequately cleaned after the previous
resident had left.
23