3. General principles of law
International courts and tribunals have traditionally considered general principles as a source
of international law, relying upon judicial reason and logic to ‘discover’ the normative rule.
Examples are to be found in the jurisprudence of the Permanent Court of International Justice
that recognised the obligation of States to make reparations on breach of the law in the
Chorzow Factory (Indemnity) case (1928) PCIJ, Series A, No 17, page 29.
In the
Mavrommatis Palestine Concessions case, the Court adopted the general principle of
subrogation (1924) PCIJ, Series A, No 2, page 28 and in the Diversion of Water from the
Mews case, Judge Hudson considered that Anglo-American equitable doctrines could be
applied as general principles. A private law doctrine of trusts was, for example, employed to
develop the concept of mandates and trusteeship in the Advisory Opinion on the Status of
South West Africa case (ICJ 1950, 146-150).
General principles of international law might also include procedural and evidentiary issues
where they are of a general character and not confined to a particular legal system.
International arbitrators in disputes such as the Texaco Case have adopted general obligations
of international commercial law. Here the arbitrator recognised the concept of an
“internationalised contract”, applying general principles of contract law to substantiate his
legal conclusions.
4. Judicial decisions and the teachings of the most highly qualified publicists
A subsidiary means of determining the rules of law are to be found in the decisions of
international courts and tribunals and in the analysis of international law in the writings of
jurists.
While international decisions have greater weight, the writings of jurists are
important in describing and analysing evolving norms and can be particularly important in
identifying principles of international human rights law. In reaching a view on issues referred
to it the ACJ is thus able to consult eminent jurists to clarify their understanding of the law.
143
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление