Promoting and Protecting the Rights of Migrant Workers The Role of National Human Rights Institutions
CASE STUDY
In 2004, the Australian Human Rights Commission published A last resort?,
the report of its national inquiry into children in immigration detention. The
inquiry was established to examine whether laws requiring the detention of
asylum-seeking children and their treatment in immigration detention met
Australia’s obligations under international law.
The Commission visited all immigration detention facilities in Australia;
organized 29 focus groups with over 200 children, parents and other
former detainees; held 61 public hearings and 24 confidential sessions; and
received 346 submissions.
5. DEVELOPING EFFECTIVE RECOMMENDATIONS
A key outcome of all public inquiries is to develop effective recommendations that will help redress past
violations of human rights and prevent future ones from occurring.
Recommendations should be based on the information and evidence collected by the inquiry; they
should meet the inquiry’s terms of reference; and they should promote compliance with national and
international human rights standards.
NHRIs can direct recommendations to any organization or individual with a role to play in addressing the
violations or improving human rights compliance. The recommendations should indicate clearly who is
to do what, when and, if possible, how. In a number of instances, they will also propose reforms to laws,
policies and practices that affect migrant workers and members of their families.
There is no “right” number of recommendations. There should be as many as are required to properly
address the issues raised by the inquiry. In general, however, an inquiry that makes a relatively succinct
set of prioritized recommendations is more likely to achieve a positive result than one that produces a
long list of non-prioritized actions.
6. PREPARING AND RELEASING THE INQUIRY REPORT
The inquiry report is an opportunity for the NHRI to build public understanding of the human rights
violations experienced by migrant workers. It should tell a clear, evidence-based and persuasive story
that generates broad community support for change and, more specifically, for implementing the
inquiry’s recommendations.
The report should be developed with these goals in mind and with a strong focus on the stories and
experiences of migrant workers. As far as possible, it should be developed and drafted as the inquiry
proceeds so that pertinent information, evidence and case studies can be included along the way.
This also means the report can be launched relatively soon after the inquiry process has been completed
and while media and community interest is still high.
To ensure factual accuracy, the NHRI can consider providing a draft report to the relevant authorities for
their comments before the final report is prepared.
While the final report must meet statutory or other requirements for official reports to the parliament,
the NHRI can also develop alternative reports to communicate the inquiry’s key findings and
recommendations with different audiences. These can include, for example, concise plain language
summary reports (in multiple languages), audio reports (in multiple languages) and video reports.
It is particularly crucial that the NHRI communicates its findings and recommendations to the migrant
workers and migrant organizations that took part in the inquiry.
128 | Chapter 9: Conducting public inquiries into systemic patterns of human rights violation
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление