Part II NHRIs in action
When some of these powers are not granted, NHRIs should carefully weigh up the advantages and
disadvantages of engaging in preventive monitoring activities. It is especially important that NHRIs are
given the authority to conduct interviews with detainees in private.286
Preventive visits are different in their purpose and methodology to those conducted with the aim of
investigating or documenting individual complaints made by detainees.
The focus of these visits is to analyse the systemic issues in relation to the place of detention and assess
all aspects related to the deprivation of liberty. The aim is to identify the risk factors and causes of those
aspects of detention which could lead to the ill-treatment of detainees or other human rights violations,
as well as provide recommendations to implement or reinforce protective strategies.287
NHRIs that undertake preventive monitoring should seek to build an ongoing and constructive dialogue
with the relevant authorities, providing concrete recommendations to improve the detention system
over the long term and then monitoring progress to implement these recommendations. In this way,
prevention is an ongoing – rather than a one-off – process.
NHRIs should also ensure there are proper accountability mechanisms in place, as well as respect for
international human rights norms and standards and national law, in privately-run places of immigration
detention.288
3.1. Undertaking visits to places of detention
Advice and recommendations for NHRIs conducting preventive visits to places of detention
is provided in Preventing Torture: An Operational Guide for National Human Rights
Institutions. It includes practical information on:
• preparing for the visit, defining the objectives and assigning responsibilities
among the visiting team
• undertaking the visit, interviewing detainees (including interviewing women and
children), touring the premises, checking the registers and engaging with the
person in charge of the facility and other staff members
• follow-up after the visit:
–– preparing a report for the detaining authority based on the findings of
the visit
–– drafting recommendations
–– other reports (thematic, annual)
–– follow-up visits.289
A basic principle of all monitoring work is to ‘do no harm’. Migrants deprived of their liberty are particularly
vulnerable, and poorly planned visits – or visits that do not follow appropriate principles and methodology
– can potentially do more harm than good.290
The Association for the Prevention of Torture recommends that NPMs and other monitoring bodies
conducting preventive visits to places of detention where migrants are detained include in their teams:
286
Preventing Torture: An Operational Guide for National Human Rights Institutions; Asia Pacific Forum of National Human Rights
Institutions, Association for the Prevention of Torture and the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights;
2010; p. 83.
287
Ibid; p. 84.
288
The Privatization of Immigration Detention: Towards a Global View; Michael Flynn and Cecilia Cannon, Global Detention Project
Working Paper No. 1; 2009.
289
Preventing Torture: An Operational Guide for National Human Rights Institutions; Asia Pacific Forum of National Human Rights
Institutions, Association for the Prevention of Torture and the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights;
2010; see Chapter 8.
290
Monitoring places of detention: A practical guide; Association for the Prevention of Torture; 2004; p. 27.
Chapter 8: Protecting the rights of migrants in detention | 113
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление