Part II NHRIs in action
In recent years, NHRIs in the Asia Pacific region have undertaken public inquiries on a broad range of
issues including: mental health and human rights; freedom from torture; forcible removal of indigenous
children from their families; access to public transport for persons with disabilities; the right to health;
and the right to food.
However, NHRIs should give close consideration to a range of factors before deciding whether it is
appropriate to establish a public inquiry to examine the issue and whether such an inquiry would be
likely to generate the systemic change required.
The dimension of the issue
Public inquiries are able to address human rights violations that affect a significant number of people
within a country. They can consider both contemporary and historical issues. Some of the human rights
issues concerning migrant workers, especially undocumented workers and migrants in an irregular
situation, have a transnational dimension, as violations can occur in countries of origin, transit and
destination. This can place some issues beyond the scope, jurisdiction or capacity of the NHRI to
investigate. However, if resources allow, NHRIs can consider establishing transnational inquiries and
gathering evidence from stakeholders in relevant countries, possibly in cooperation with the NHRIs in
those countries. NHRIs in different countries can also consider establishing joint inquiries into human
rights issues of shared concern, such as human trafficking.
The complexity of the issue
Public inquiries are most effective when they engage a broad range of stakeholders to examine a specific
issue in detail and from a variety of perspectives. Depending on the inquiry subject, NHRIs can collect
evidence from, and make recommendations to, a wide range of individuals and organizations who
share responsibility for promoting and protecting the rights of migrant workers, including government
departments, law enforcement agencies, immigration detention authorities, private and public sector
employers, business groups, professional associations and accreditation bodies, private recruitment
agencies, trade unions and NGOs. The inquiry can and should consider steps to promote the civil,
political, economic, social and cultural rights of migrant workers, which require responses and action
from many different stakeholders.
The nature of the human rights issue
A public inquiry is an effective way to examine, explain and propose solutions to a serious, systemic
human rights issue. By collecting evidence from a variety of sources, the inquiry process can develop
understanding among stakeholders and the broader community on the nature of the problem, its human
rights dimensions, the need to address it and how this can best be done. By building public awareness
and support, the inquiry can generate political pressure to implement practical solutions that ensure
greater fairness and dignity for migrant workers and members of their families. To achieve these goals, it
is essential that the inquiry is conducted in public. Some issues are particularly sensitive and, as a result,
key stakeholders may only be willing or able to provide evidence on a confidential basis. If this is the
case, it may not be appropriate to try and address the issue through a public inquiry.
The capacity of the NHRI
Undertaking a public inquiry requires a significant financial commitment by the NHRI, as well as an inquiry
team of NHRI members and staff with the expertise to liaise with stakeholders, collect evidence, undertake
research, engage the media, write the inquiry report and advocate for the inquiry’s recommendations.
The decision to conduct a public inquiry must be based on a realistic assessment of the resources, both
financial and human, that will be required over the course of the inquiry and during the follow-up stage.
A poorly planned or executed inquiry can seriously undermine the credibility of NHRI, especially among
victims, witnesses and other key stakeholders who have supported the inquiry and given evidence.
Some organizations or individuals may attempt to block access to relevant information or refuse to
Chapter 9: Conducting public inquiries into systemic patterns of human rights violation | 123
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление