Part II NHRIs in action
This can include making public recommendations to strengthen a country’s legal framework, including
advocating that the Government ratify the Optional Protocol to the Convention against Torture; monitoring
places of detention where migrants are held; recommending alternatives to detention for migrants in
an irregular situation; promoting their access to justice and legal services; training public officials; and
raising public awareness of the issues facing migrants in detention.
Every person who is deprived of their liberty is placed in situation of vulnerability. However, some
individuals face greater risk of human rights violations because of their particular characteristics and/or
situational factors.256
It is therefore important that NHRIs pay particular attention to the needs of vulnerable groups of migrants
in detention, including children, women, older people, people with disabilities, people who have been
trafficked for the purpose of sexual exploitation and people who have experienced torture in their country
of origin.
To work effectively in this area, NHRIs should seek to develop partnerships with individuals and
organizations with specialized skills and understanding of the migration and refugee sector.
2. STRENGTHENING THE NATIONAL LEGAL FRAMEWORK
NHRIs shall advocate for a human rights approach to migration and migration management.
NHRIs underline that each State is responsible to guarantee respect for the human rights and
fundamental freedoms of all persons regardless of their migration status.
Santa Cruz Declaration257
It is the sovereign right of each country to determine and enforce their policies on migration. However,
in an increasingly globalized international community, States also have a legal and moral obligation to
respect the human rights of all people within their jurisdiction, regardless of their migration status.
The International Commission of Jurists notes that:
International standards establish that, in immigration control, detention should be the exception
rather than the rule, and should be a measure of last resort, to be imposed only where other
less restrictive alternatives, such as reporting requirements or restrictions on residence, are not
feasible in the individual case.258
NHRIs have a clear mandate to ensure that their State’s laws and policies regarding the treatment and
management of migrants, especially those in an irregular situation, comply with international human
rights standards and international customary law.
Refugees, asylum seekers, undocumented workers and persons who have been smuggled or
trafficked across borders are commonly held in administrative detention while awaiting deportation
or a determination of their migration status. This places already vulnerable individuals in situations of
additional risk and anxiety.
Therefore, NHRIs have a particular responsibility to ensure that the legal framework governing the
detention of migrants can and does protect their rights in practice.
256
Protecting asylum-seekers, refugees and migrants in detention; APT Position Paper; Association for the Prevention of Torture;
2012; p. 1.
257
Santa Cruz Declaration; Eighth International Conference of National Institutions for the Promotion and Protection of Human
Rights; Santa Cruz, Republic of Bolivia; 24–26 October 2006; para. 14.
258
Migration and International Human Rights Law; Practitioner’s Guide No. 6; International Commission of Jurists; 2011; p. 147.
Chapter 8: Protecting the rights of migrants in detention | 105
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление