Promoting and Protecting the Rights of Migrant Workers The Role of National Human Rights Institutions
Depending on the nature of the issues under consideration, the NHRI could establish a public inquiry or
it could collect information and evidence from parties on a confidential basis.
Whichever approach the NHRI adopts, it is essential that the inquiry’s objectives and methods of
operation are clearly communicated with all relevant stakeholders. The inquiry should be based on the
principle of procedural fairness.
As with the process for handling individual complaints, collecting evidence is fundamental to an effective
inquiry. For inquiries into systemic issues, this could include:
• collecting and reviewing documentation from relevant government departments, private sector
bodies and civil society organizations
• analysing legislation and government policies against national and international human rights
standards, as well as recommendations made to the State by the UN human rights treaty bodies,
the special procedures and through the Universal Periodic Review
• undertaking visits to particular sites where violations are alleged to have occurred (e.g. ports
and border crossings, places of detention, individual workplaces and employer-provided
accommodation)
• conducting interviews with relevant individuals and organizations, which may include victims,
witnesses, respondent organizations, government departments, trade unions, NGOs, migrant
organizations and experts in the field.
In some circumstances the NHRI may be required to use its legal authority to compel cooperation of
parties in the inquiry process. The NHRI may also receive information or conduct interviews with victims
or witnesses on a confidential basis, in order to avoid the potential for reprisals or victimization.
Based on the findings of the inquiry, the NHRI should develop recommendations that seek to provide
redress for the human rights violations that were found to have occurred. They should be “broad enough
to ensure that the violations stop, that similar violations do not occur, that sanctions are applied where
this is warranted and that victims are “made whole” where this is possible and appropriate”.249
NHRIs should hold the Government and government agencies accountable for grave violations of
human rights, including threats to life, physical integrity and the human dignity of migrants while they are
attempting to cross borders or while at the hands of the authorities.250
The findings and recommendations of the inquiry can be included in the annual report of the NHRI or in
a standalone inquiry report presented to the parliament. The inquiry report can be made public to build
community understanding of the issues facing migrant workers and to generate discussion and support
for the recommendations.
NHRIs should strongly advocate for the full implementation of their recommendations and monitor the
steps taken by the Government, business entities251 and other relevant parties to comply with human
rights standards, particularly as they apply to migrant workers.
More information on establishing and undertaking public inquiries is included in Chapter 9.
249
National Human Rights Institutions: History, Principles, Roles and Responsibilities; Professional Training Series No. 4 (Rev. 1);
Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights; 2010; p. 96.
250
Rabat Declaration on Migration and Human Rights; 3rd Arab-European NHRIs’ Dialogue on Migration and Human Rights; Rabat,
Morocco; 6–8 May 2008.
251
Edinburgh Declaration; 10th International Conference of National Institutions for the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights;
Edinburgh, Scotland; 8–10 October 2010; Section C ‘Complaints Handling’, para. IV: “NHRIs with complaint handling functions
could consider [u]tilising their complaints mechanisms, and the outcomes of complaints and inquiries, to monitor on-going
practices of business entities.”
100 | Chapter 7: Investigating allegations of human rights violations
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление