Australian Human Rights Commission
Report title October 2022
142. The Senate Community Affairs References Committee considered the use
of restrictive practices in relation to people with disability in 2016. The
Committee recommended that the Australian Government work with State
and Territory governments to implement a national zero-tolerance approach
to eliminate restrictive practices in all service delivery contexts.216 This issue
is currently being examined by the Disability Royal Commission.217
143. Australia has not implemented a nationally consistent supported decisionmaking framework and lacks legislation prohibiting the sterilisation of
people with disability without consent.218 The Commission remains deeply
concerned that the non-therapeutic sterilisation of people with disability,
particularly women and girls219 continues to take place in Australia without
their free, prior and informed consent. The Commission is also concerned by
the forced administration of contraceptives and abortion procedures.220 The
Commission encourages the Australian Government to work with state and
territory governments to adopt uniform legislation prohibiting forced
sterilisation and abortions in the absence of the free, prior and informed
consent of the person concerned.
144. The Commission remains concerned that mental health laws, frameworks
and policies in Australia permit the provision of mental health services to
people with psychosocial disability and mental health conditions in ways
that breach their human rights, including their right to liberty and
security.221 The Commission is particularly concerned about the imposition
of compulsory treatment and involuntary hospitalisation.222 Almost one in
five (19.9%) residential mental health care episodes were for people with an
involuntary mental health legal status during 2019–20.223 State and territory
approaches are inconsistent in this regard. The Commission recommends
that all mental health laws, frameworks and policies be examined and
reformed to ensure alignment with human rights standards.
145. There remain high rates of violence against people with disability, 224 in
particular women and girls.225 Initiatives aimed at addressing violence
against women and children often fail to adequately address the extra
challenges faced by people with disability.
Recommendation 36: Governments develop a nationally consistent
framework to reduce and eliminate the use of restrictive practices.
Recommendation 37: Governments adopt a human rights-based approach
to mental health laws and ensure that mental health services do not
violate the human rights of people with disability.
35