60
2020 Annual Report on the Human Rights Situation in the Philippines
remind government officials, in particular the security sector, to focus on promoting the
rights and freedom enjoyed by the people, instead of perpetuating fear and distrust among
them as they speak on behalf of the voiceless.256
203
On 6 May 2019, human rights group Karapatan, women’s group Gabriela, and religious
group Rural Missionaries of the Philippines (RMP), went to the Supreme Court and
filed a petition for the issuance of writ of Amparo and Habeas Data. The protection order
was requested against the entire military sector and Malacañang officials. The filing of
the petition spurred harassment tactics against them. There were posters vilifying them,
incidents of tailing, and threatening messages. They juxtaposed these with public statements
of military officials calling them communist fronts.
204
The Supreme Court granted the writs and remanded the case to the Court of Appeals
(CA). In the CA, the hearing was for the purpose of determining final judgment – to grant
the privileges or not. Due to procedural misunderstandings at the CA, witnesses were not
allowed to go on the stand. Among the witnesses, was Zara Alvarez, who was to testify on
the vile red-tagging against her and her colleagues in Negros and across the country. As
stated in her 2019 sworn statement I have also experienced being detained for crimes I did
not commit and I fear that it may happen again or I might be killed like what happened
to the many farmers of Negros as well as Tatay Toto and Atty. Ben Ramos.257 The CA
proceeded without hearing them, and in June 2019, denied the petition.258
205
On the celebration of the Human Rights Day on 10 December, the PNP-CIDG also
launched a string of operations that led to the arrest of a journalist and six trade unionists
on charges of alleged possession of firearms and explosives.259 The arrested individuals were
Lady Ann Salem, Dennise Velasco, Mark Ryan Cruz, Romina Raiselle Astudillo, Jaymie
Gregorio, Joel Demate, and Rodrigo Esparago.
206
Such arrests are cause for concern given that there were statements by families and concerned
personalities alleging irregularities and errors in the said operations, including the fact that
arrests were made in the midst of red-tagging of activists and human rights workers.
207
It would be beneficial for the government, particularly the PNP, to address these doubts
and allegations of anomalous arrests, especially since several pronouncements were already
made by this administration—here and abroad—on its commitment to respect and protect
the human rights of all.260
208
The CHR in its July 2020 report said that President Rodrigo Duterte created “a dangerous
fiction” against activists and defenders. Groups reported an increasing number of incidents
of red-tagging and harassment since June 2020. Groups claimed that there was clear
intent to associate their names, faces, and organizations with violence, including rampant
256
See http://chr.gov.ph/statement-of-commissioner-gwendolyn-pimentel-gana-on-the-warning-made-by-a-militaryofficial-to-liza-soberano-and-catriona-gray/.
257
Navallo, Mike. “‘I might be killed’: Karapatan shows slain Zara Alvarez’s 2019 affidavit seeking protection,” ABS-CBN
News, 1 September 2020, available at https://news.abs-cbn.com/news/09/01/20/i-might-be-killed-karapatan-showssc-slain-activist-zara-alvarezs-2019-affidavit-seeking-protection, accessed 18 December 2020.
258
Buan, Lian. “Zara Alvarez asked for protection, but she died before the court could give it,” Rappler, 20 August
2020, available at https://www.rappler.com/nation/zara-alvarez-petition-writ-amparo-habeas-data-court, accessed 18
December 2020.
259
Talabong, Rambo. “PNP goes on arresting spree on Human Rights Day,” Rappler, 10 December 2020, available
at https://www.rappler.com/nation/pnp-arresting-spree-human-rights-day-december-10-2020, accessed 18
December2020.
260
Commission on Human Rights. Statement of CHR spokesperson, Atty. Jacqueline Ann de Guia, on the string of
arrests on Human Rights Day, 13 December 2020, available at http://chr.gov.ph/statement-of-chr-spokesperson-atty –
jacqueline-ann-de-guia-on-the-string-of-arrests-on-human-rights-day/, accessed 18 December 2020.