4. Discrimination law reform
However, the compliance framework that
operates alongside this is extremely limited.
Individual complainants, and the alternative
dispute resolution (ADR) process, should not
bear the bulk of responsibility for ensuring
compliance with discrimination laws.
The Regulatory Powers Act commenced on
1 October 2014, but only has effect where
Commonwealth Acts are drafted or amended to
trigger its provisions. As the Attorney‑General’s
Department explained:
Implementation of the Regulatory Powers
Act supports the government's regulatory
reform agenda, as it simplifies and
streamlines Commonwealth regulatory
powers across the statute book.13
As Associate Professor Belinda Smith observed:
Anti-discrimination legislation is designed
to protect disempowered groups – those
who traditionally experience marginalisation
and exclusion. Expecting members of
such groups to have the time, security and
resources to pursue legal action in order to
gain compensation and possibly bring about
wider change represents a fundamental
regulatory weakness.10
The Commission’s ADR powers have remained
largely as they were at the establishment of
the first iteration of the Commission in 1981.
However, the Commission’s additional powers
which were established in 1986 and which
revolved around a hearing and determination
function were reduced in 2000, in response to
the High Court’s decision in Brandy v Human
Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission.11
At the same time, other regulatory agencies
have had their frameworks modernised, with a
broader suite of regulatory powers and options
to aid compliance and address non-compliance.
In 2014, the Australian Government
introduced the Regulatory Powers Act to
provide ‘a framework of standard regulatory
powers exercised by agencies across the
Commonwealth’.
Regulatory powers are the suite of different
tools used by government agencies to
ensure individuals and industry comply with
legislative requirements. The key features of the
Regulatory Powers Act include monitoring and
investigation powers as well as enforcement
provisions, through the use of civil penalty
provisions, infringement notices, enforceable
undertakings and injunctions.12
The range of powers included in the Regulatory
Powers Act are:
• monitoring powers, which can be used to
monitor compliance with provisions of an Act
and to monitor whether information given to
the Commonwealth is correct (Part 2)
• investigation powers, which can be used
to gather material that relates to the
contravention of an offence or civil penalty
provision (Part 3)
• the power to apply to a court for civil penalty
orders and injunctions (Parts 4 and 7)
• the power to issue infringement notices
(Part 5)
• the power to accept and seek enforcement
of undertakings relating to compliance with
legislative provisions (Part 6).14
The Explanatory Memorandum noted it was
expected that, over time, ‘existing regulatory
regimes will be reviewed and, if appropriate,
amended to instead trigger the relevant
provisions of the Regulatory Powers Bill’.15
Provisions in existing legislation would be
replaced with references to the standard
provisions as appropriate – some legislative
schemes would wholly adopt these standard
provisions, and some would adopt some of the
provisions while maintaining their own unique
provisions as appropriate.
In the period since 2014, there has been
no consideration as to whether federal
discrimination law should be amended by
adding new regulatory provisions covered in
the Regulatory Powers Act.
FREE & EQUAL: Revitalising Australia’s Commitment to Human Rights
85