Australian Human Rights Commission
Current issues and good practices in prison management, 16 November 2023
46. The Australian Institute of Health and Welfare reports that, on an average day
in 2021–22, 18% (822) of young people aged 10 and over who were under
youth justice supervision were in detention and almost 3 in 4 were
unsentenced (76%). More than half (452 or 55%) of the young people in
detention on an average day in 2021–22 were First Nations young people.72
3.1
Criminal age of responsibility
47. The Commission considers the minimum age of criminal responsibility in
Australia, of 10 years, to be too low. While offending by young children should
not go unaddressed, criminalising children for their behaviour at such a
young age is ineffective at preventing future offending behaviour while also
running counter to human rights.
48. Raising the age of criminal responsibility alone will not solve the problem of
youth offending. However, it is hoped that raising the age will open the door
to a new approach to dealing with the younger cohort of offenders, one that
focuses on their welfare, and which aims to prevent future offending and
reduce recidivism. As has been noted by the Australian and New Zealand
Children's Commissioners and Guardians, what is required in Australia is for
‘all jurisdictions to prioritise the twin actions of legislating to raise the age of
criminal responsibility and implementing holistic systems of early
intervention and diversion’.73
49. In March 2022, the Queensland Legislative Assembly’s Community Support
and Services Committee examined the Criminal Law (Raising the Age of
Responsibility) Amendment Bill 2021, which seeks to raise the age of criminal
responsibility from 10 to 14. The Committee did not recommend the Bill be
passed; but recommended the Queensland Government continue to work on
raising the minimum age of criminal responsibility to 12.74 The Bill
subsequently failed to pass in August 2022.
50. In June 2022, the Tasmanian Government committed to raising the age of
detention from 10 to 14 by the end of 2024.75 In July 2023, the Commissioner
for Children and Young People (Tasmania) released a Memorandum of Advice
to the Tasmanian Government to assist the transition of raising the age and
better promote the wellbeing of children.76 In September 2023, the
Commission of Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse recommended the Tasmanian
Government ‘[i]ntroduce legislation to increase the minimum age of criminal
responsibility to 14 years, without exception’.77
51. In November 2022, the Northern Territory Legislative Assembly passed the
Criminal Code Amendment Act 2022, that raised the age of criminal
responsibility from 10 to 12, coming into effect on 1 August 2023.78 The
12