Summary of Presentations
1 Dr Pat Tuohy, Chief Advisor (Child and
Youth Health) to the Ministry of Health
•
Dr Pat Tuohy represented the New Zealand
government at the fifth periodic report of New
Zealand to the UN Committee on the Rights of
the Child (UNCRC) in Geneva 2016 where New
Zealand was questioned on the rights of intersex
children.
• Dr Tuohy addressed the recommendations of the
UNCRC and noted that the changes needed will
be a transitional process and won’t be finished
until society as a whole rejects the binary nature
of gender that drives much of what health
practitioners do in the field of intersex
healthcare.
• The offer of adding an Intersex Clinical Network
to the Paediatric Society of New Zealand Clinical
Network group, funded via the Ministry of
Health, was introduced. The practicalities of
how such clinical networks have worked for
other key health topics were explained. Dr
Tuohy acknowledged that the establishment
of this group would not meet all of the
recommendations from the UNCRC but would
be a good foundation for further work.
• The complex issues on working in consultation
with parents around consent were highlighted.
It was noted that both clinicians and whänau
need access to education in this area. Mobilising
support in communities would be key to
achieving positive lifelong outcomes for
intersex people.
2 Mani Mitchell, Executive Director
of the Intersex Trust of Aotearoa
New Zealand (ITANZ)
• Mani Mitchell provided an update to the
Roundtable and their international and national
advocacy over the last 12 months.
• Acknowledged the important relationship
between the NZ Human Rights Commission and
ITANZ, with special mention to the foundational
support of Dame Margaret Sparrow, Sir Paul
Reeves, and Rosslyn Noonan.
• Briefed the Roundtable participants on the United
Nations Human Rights mandates and the issues
faced by intersex people. Updates from the UN
Committee on the Rights of the Child, the UN
Committee Against Torture, the UN World Health
Organization, and the UN High Commissioner for
Human Rights were presented to the group.
ey updates from ITANZ’s work over the
° K
last 12 months include:
ublication of the Astrea Foundation
° P
We Are Real report3.
submission by ITANZ to the UN Committee
° A
Against Torture in preparation for New
Zealand’s review under the 7th periodic cycle.
This resulted in a request by the Committee
to New Zealand in their list of issues prior to
reporting to comment on “premature surgery
and other medical treatment to which intersex
children are subjected,” and to “indicate
the number of intersex children who have
undergone sex assignment surgery during the
reporting period.”4
he Sydney intersex retreat and the
° T
publication of the Darlington Statement.5
8
Human Rights Commission