Annual Report 1999-2000
station, Dibai, and met the Sub-Inspector and later the Fire Station Officer, both of
whom, instead of taking cognizance of the case, abused the girl, passed derogatory
remarks and also threatened them with implication in false cases. Upon returning home,
ABC committed suicide by setting herself on fire and later succumbed to her bum
injuries at 9 a.m. on 15 August 1998.
As the complaint related to a grave violation of human rights of a Dalit girl, the
Commission took cognizance of this matter on a priority basis, and issued notice to the
SSP, Bulandshar, calling for a report. The report dated 6 October 1998, received from
the SSP, Bulandshar, stated that the complainant had denied having sent the complaint
in question to the Commission, but confirmed the averments and allegations made in
the complaint with regard to the suicide by ABC after she was raped by the two firemen.
It was also reported that, upon a complaint of the grandfather of the victim, a case FIR
No. 221/98 under Section 363/366/376/306, IPC, and under Secdon 3(1)/12 of the
SC/ST Act had been registered, and efforts were on to arrest the accused persons.
Upon considering the report, the Commission thought it expedient to get the matter
inquired into by its own investigation division. Pursuant to this decision, an Inspector
from the investigation division made an on-the-spot enquiry and submitted a report.
According to the report, ABC had developed illicit relations with the two firemen. On
the night of 14 August 1998, she had been taken by them to their rented house, where
she had been sexually exploited. The next day, ABC approached the Fire Station Officer
and the SHO to complain about the rape, but neither took cognizance of the case.
Thereafter, the girl committed suicide by burning herself. A case ivas registered on
17 August 1998, but only after a protest and a road blockade by the residents of the
village. The report of the investigation team also indicated that the station diary for 16
August 1998, had been tampered with. It was also observed that while the SHO had
visited the scene of the crime, he did not record the dying declaration of ABC, though
she was capable of giving one at that time.
Upon perusing the report, the Commission held that SHO, Dibai, and the in-charge. Fire
Station, Dibai, had not conducted themselves in a manner befitting tiieir office and
responsibilities, and that they had not only shown a lack of sensitivity in a matter of grave
importance, namely the protection of a Dalit girl subjected to sexual assault, but had been
thoroughly negligent in not taking cognizance of the complaint lodged by ABC. Instead,
the Commission noted, they had allegedly made derogatory and uncharitable remarks
about the girl. The Commission observed that the attitude of these two officers had
driven ABC to take the extreme step of ending her life by setting herself on fire, having
been left with the impression that she would not get justice. The Commission further
observed that the remarks and inaction on the part of the officials might, perhaps, make
them liable for the offence of abetment of suicide by ABC, which was punishable under
Section 306, IPC, and needed to be investigated.
130