Annual Report 1999-2000
not attracted to this body as, indeed, it does not function under the provisions of the
"Act", but under the remit of the Supreme Court'. As a logical consequence, the powers
of the Commission in carrying out this mandate are not limited by Section 36(2) or other
limiting provisions, if any, under the "Act",* the Commission ruled.
The Commission also 'answered in the negative', the objections relating to the legality
of the alleged delegation of authority by the Supreme Court, stating that the Court's
order made it clear that it had 'not created any exclusive final adjudicatory jurisdiction
in the Commission', but implied that 'the Commission discharged its functions as an
instrumentality or agency of the Court'.
The Commission further stated that it would need to greatly augment its logistical
capability; it would have to induct officers withjudicial experience to record and process
the evidence and conduct enquiries under the directions of the Commission, and
recommend appropriate compensation subject to final endorsement by the Commission.
On receipt of the above order of the Commission, the Ministry of Home Affairs filed
a petition seeking clarification of the Supreme Court's order of 12 December 1996, in
the light of Commission's orders settling the objections of the Government of India and
laying down modalities which it intended to follow in pursuing the enquiry into this case.
On 10 September 1998, the Supreme Court disposed ofthe said petition, upholding the
stand of the Commission that it was a hoAy sui generis, in addition to it being a body sui
juris createdunder the Act of Parliament. The Supreme Court criticised the Union Home
Ministry for the various objections raised by it before the Commission, and for later
approaching the Court for clarifications, which had led to delay in providing relief to
the affected families.
Thereafter, the Commission proceeded to examine the scope of the enquiry, which it
was required to undertake under the remit of the Supreme Court's order dated 12
December 1996. While it was contended on behalf of the petitioners that the Commission
was required to enquire into all incidents of what were referred to as extra-judicial
eliminations, or involuntary disappearances, fake encounters, abductions and killings
etc., alleged against the Punjab police during the decade 1984-1994, the Union
Government and the State of Punjab contended that the enquiry should be restricted
only to the 2,097 cases of cremation of bodies—585 fully identified, 274 partially
identified and 1,238 unidentified—in the police districts of Amritsar, Tarn Taran
and Majitha.
After hearing the Counsel for the parties, the Commission in its order dated 13
January 1999, settled the scope of enquiry under the Supreme Court's direction, by
holding that it was limited only to those illegal killings/disappearances that culminated
in the cremation of 2,097 bodies (585 bodies fully identified, 274 bodies partially
identified and 1,238 bodies unidentified), in the crematoria located at Durgyana Mandir,
150
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление