One leading authority for racial harassment is Corbett
v UDP Shoplifters Ltd.354 In this case, the claimant had
been subject to derogatory remarks about his Irish
heritage from his colleagues, and when he raised the
abuse with his managers, he continued to receive
abuse and ended up being assaulted and then
leaving his job.355 His claim was successful in meeting
the elements of s 109 on the grounds that his fellow
employees had expressed “hostility” toward him, that
he was brought into “contempt or ridicule” on the
basis of his national origin, he was upset by the abuse
and the abuse had a “detrimental effect” on his job
satisfaction, causing him to leave the job.356
Another leading case for racial harassment
under s 109 of the Act is Bashir v Ladbrook Law
Ltd, which concerned derogatory remarks made
about the claimant’s ability to speak English and
their first language being Arabic.357 Despite the
employer arguing that their remarks were not racial
harassment because “that written English can be
difficult for non-native speakers was a fact”, the claim
was successful as it was noted that the claimant had
achieved academic merit in English and had obtained
a law degree from a New Zealand university, thus
making the remarks racial harassment on the
grounds of race or ethnic origin.358
The Corbett and Bashir cases make it clear that an
employer will be held liable for the racial harassment
of their employee unless they can prove that they
took all reasonably practicable steps to prevent the
harassment from occurring.359
7.3 Addressing workplace racism with
cultural competency training
To date, there has been no research into how New
Zealand workplaces and wider society can begin
to engage with New Zealand’s colonial history
in the Pacific Islands. This is an important gap in
literature and practice as it is our colonial history
that contributes to the devaluing of Pacific labour
today. However, the recent Dawn Raids apology and
the subsequent dedicated resourcing have potential
to begin this urgent conversation. This final section
therefore explores a commonly suggested solution to
racism in the workplace, which is cultural competency
training. Cultural competency training has become
an area of focus in relation to potential solutions to
racism against Pacific peoples in the workplace and
the Pacific Pay Gap.360 By understanding the cultural
framework in which Pacific peoples operate, there
is an opportunity to design workplace solutions to
secure Pacific employment retention and mobility
and minimise underemployment and unemployment
for Pacific peoples in Aotearoa New Zealand.361
7.3.1 Employers and cultural competency
There is evidence that racist stereotypes impact
non-Pacific managers’ interpretations of Pacific
workers’ actions at work, which subsequently impacts
decisions regarding how to engage with and support
or promote Pacific workers.362 Non-Pacific employers
repeatedly report that their lack of understanding of
Pacific culture is a significant barrier to their ability
to foster positive workplace environments for Pacific
workers.363 Cultural competency training can provide
354
Corbett v UDP Shoplifters Ltd [2012] NZERA Christchurch 151.
355
Corbett v UDP Shoplifters Ltd, [2].
356
Corbett v UDP Shoplifters Ltd, [41]-[44].
357
Bashir v Ladbrook Law Ltd [2016] NZERA Auckland 73.
358
Bashir v Ladbrook Law Ltd, [25]-[39].
359
Hornsby-Geluk, Susan. “The Lesson from Roseanne for New Zealand Employers.” Stuff, June 13, 2018. https://www.stuff.
co.nz/business/opinion-analysis/104476793/roseannes-lessons-for-kiwi-employers?fbclid=IwAR0O14Ubwlw1z5mDZQAqfxY6
adwg_B3RfFZL9R9iVsZL-cGy7iMl0u8YvTo
360
Ministry for Pacific Peoples. Pacific Employment Action Plan, 5.
361
Tunoa, Alofa. Pacific Peoples’ Progression in the Labour Market: A Literature Review. Undated, 35; Auckland Co-design Lab, The
Attitude Gap Challenge, 100-101.
362
Tupou, “The Effect of the Glass Ceiling,” 52; Department of Labour, In Harm’s Way, 46, 53; Ministry for Pacific Peoples, Pacific
Employment Action Plan, 5; Radio New Zealand, “Workplace Challenges for Pasifika Peoples.”
363
The Southern Initiative, Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment, and Auckland Co-design Lab, Pacific Peoples’
Workforce Challenge, 14, 18; Auckland Co-design Lab, The Attitude Gap Challenge, 45, 66; Department of Labour, In Harm’s
Way, 50-51.
Pacific Pay Gap Inquiry Literature Review
51