their narrow margin of survival makes the Orang Asli’s health situation
precarious. They are also vulnerable to natural hazards and the whims of
ecosystem destruction by others.
Scape-goating
Blaming the victim instead of oneself appears to be quite commonplace in
administrative dealings with Orang Asli, especially in matters about health.
For example, in October 1985, when 23 FELDA settlers in Trolak, Perak,
came down with jaundice, the health authorities were quick to blame the
nearby Semai village and to call for its resettlement. This call was made on
the ‘possibility’ and ‘feelings’ that the Semai were contaminating the water
supply by their unhygienic practices. Although another 1,057 people in the
district had come down with jaundice in the preceding month, no drastic
action like resettlement was suggested for non-Orang Asli communities. As
it turned out, the cause of the outbreak was insufficient chlorination at the
treatment plant (The Star 18 October 1985, 2 December 1985).
In February 1997, when two Jah Hut children in Kuala Krau, Pahang died
from an overdose of anti-malarials irresponsibly dispensed by a health
department team, the authorities denied it was their fault and suggested
that the deaths were due to the parents’ negligence. A coroner’s inquiry,
however, ruled that the cause of death was in fact an overdose of antimalarials (Toh 2000, Nicholas 1997, Baer 1999). Notably, this was the fourth
fatal incident arising out of the anti-malaria programme in the same state!
In April 2004, when four Semai children died within five days with symptoms
of vomiting and diarrhoea, the authorities were quick to attribute the
tragedy to salmonella poisoning—and, consequently, the poor hygiene of
the Orang Asli (Husairy Othman 2004). The government reiterated that it
could only provide proper health facilities and infrastructure if the Orang
Asli were resettled. The Health Minister who made this comment did not
realise that RPS Terisu in Cameron Highlands, where the tragic deaths
occurred, was a resettlement scheme and had been so for many years! The
cause of the deaths was eventually found to be a rota-virus infection.
44
ORANG ASLI – RIGHTS, PROBLEMS & SOLUTIONS