12. Are the selected policies evidence-based, rational, and achievable? Is the reasoning
transparent and publicly available?
Human rights are often characterised as idealistic and impractical, but this is a serious
misrepresentation. Human rights depend upon a blend of values (see 1 above) and evidence of
what works (see 4 above). In line with democratic values, they also require as much transparency
as possible.
13. How are priorities being set and trade-offs being made?
Prioritisation and trade-offs are common features of every approach to policy making, including
the human rights approach. The human rights approach, grounded on te Tiriti, places conditions
on the policy-making process, for example:
•
priority should be given to the poorest and most disadvantaged individuals and
communities
•
equity, equality, and non-discrimination rule out any trade-offs that would result in or
deepen unequal and discriminatory outcomes.
For more information on prioritisation and trade-offs, see the Human Rights Commission’s
Guidelines.27
14. How does the decision-making process support inclusivity and participation?
The critical importance of enhancing inclusivity and diversity is widely accepted in Aotearoa.
Inclusivity and diversity are buttressed by the human rights of equity, equality, and nondiscrimination. For more information on equity, equality and non-discrimination, see the Human
Rights Commission’s Guidelines.28 Regarding participation, see 5 above.
Step 4: Implementation
Put the selected policies into action
15. Who has responsibility for implementing the selected policies?
See 11 above and 19 and 20 below.
16. How are resources being allocated to ensure that the most disadvantaged groups benefit
from the selected policies?
As emphasised, human rights have a particular preoccupation with equity, equality, nondiscrimination, diversity, and inclusivity – in other words, disadvantaged groups. This
preoccupation inevitably leads to questions about whether the allocation of resources benefits
disadvantaged groups. See 2, 13 and 14 above.
17. How are Māori and other disadvantaged groups being included in the implementation
process?
See 5 above.
2. Integrating human rights and te Tiriti o Waitangi into housing policy making
21