However, the Human Rights Act could apply
to courts when they are operating in an
administrative capacity – in circumstances
where courts act similarly to other public
authorities captured within the Human Rights
Act. Administrative functions for courts
include, for example, committal proceedings,
the issuing of warrants, listing cases, hiring
staff and adopting practices and procedures.55
It has been established in Victoria that an
administrative decision by a decision maker
who is required to act judicially, remains
administrative in character.56 Federal tribunals
are wholly administrative in nature, and cannot
exercise judicial functions – there is therefore no
constitutional concern with including them as
public authorities within a Human Rights Act.57
Additionally, there is scope for Human Rights
Act rights to apply to the procedural functions
of courts. Specifically, the right to a fair trial and
equality before the law as implemented through
the Human Rights Act could inform court
procedures. The Commission considers that
this approach is unlikely to be of constitutional
concern. As noted by Williams and Hume,
‘there is a distinction between Parliament
commandeering a court (which may be
prohibited) and Parliament merely regulating
a court’s processes (which is permitted)’.58 The
Nicholas case established that ‘Parliament has
the power to regulate judicial proceedings, at
least so long as it does not direct that facts exist
or be found, or direct a verdict’.59 In Nicholas,
Gaudron J elaborated essential features of a
court, stating that a court could not be:
152
required or authorised to proceed in a
manner that does not ensure equality
before the law, impartiality and the
appearance of impartiality, the right of a
party to meet the case made against him
or her, the independent determination of
the matter in controversy by application of
the law to facts determined in accordance
with rules and procedures which truly
permit the facts to be ascertained, and
in the case of criminal proceedings, the
determination of guilt or innocence by
means of a fair trial according to law.60
The application of a Human Rights Act to the
procedural functions of the courts would not
raise any of the concerns listed by Gaudron
J and would serve to enhance principles of
procedural fairness.
In Victoria, while the Charter explicitly applies
to the courts operating in their administrative
capacity, the Charter has been interpreted also
to apply to courts where it arises in relation
to court proceedings. The Victorian approach
is outlined in the box below. The Commission
proposes that this be adopted in a federal
Human Rights Act, and made explicit in the text
of the Human Rights Act – to avoid some of
the complexities associated with the Victorian
case law, resulting from the somewhat vague
directions under the Victorian Charter.
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление