Victorian Charter: preventative audits
and protocols
The Charter has played a significant role in
‘prompting identification of potential issues in
advance’ and through this, influencing policy
development and decision-making processes.
As an example, following the implementation of
the Charter, the Victoria Police Human Rights
Unit Project identified various policies and
practices, which have the potential to result in
human rights violations. They conducted policy
and practice audits into a range of units within
the agency including: the Aboriginal Advisory
Unit; the Gay and Lesbian Liaison Unit; the MultiCultural Advisory Unit; the Prisoner Management
Unit; the Witness Security Unit; and the
The outcome of these audits in some units
resulted in the development of protocols, which
aim to ensure that the risk of Charter violations
is minimised.
In addition, Victoria Police:
• audited police cells and holding rooms
and reviewed its persons in custody policy
to ensure compliance with human rights
standards
• referenced the Charter in Operational
Safety and Tactics training guides, and
• ensured that complaints handling
procedures are in line with human rights
standards.
Strategic Research Unit.
Extracted from Human Rights Law Centre, 2012.11
6.2 Nature of the duty
The requirement to ‘act’ compatibly with
human rights is a substantive obligation on
public authorities.13 An ‘act’ includes a failure,
refusal and proposal to act – and may also
include ‘decisions’ in terms of a substantive
decision that is made (as opposed to human
rights consideration in the course of decision
making).14 Where a public authority has limited
or interfered with a right through its action or
inaction, and any limitation on the right was not
reasonable or justified, this would constitute
breach of the substantive limb.15
(a) Limbs of the duty
Under the state and territory approaches there
are two limbs of the positive duty. They are a
duty to:
• give proper consideration to human rights
when making decisions; and
• act compatibly with human rights
The requirement to give ‘proper consideration’
to human rights applies to making decisions
and implementing legislation and policy – it is
a procedural obligation. Decision makers must
seriously turn their mind to the possible impact
of a decision on a person’s human rights, and
must identify and balance competing interests
or rights when making a decision, to comply
with this limb of the duty.12
142
Most human rights are not absolute, and
circumstances may require that different
rights be balanced against important public
interests, and countervailing rights. The positive
duty requires consideration of, and action in
accordance with, the criteria in the ‘limitations
clause’. The limitations clause sets out a formula
for permissible limitations on human rights, and
is discussed in detail in chapter 9, section 9.5.
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление