Victorian Charter approach
Section 4(1)(j)
Section 4(1)(j) explicitly excludes from
the definition of public authorities ‘a court
or tribunal except when it is acting in an
administrative capacity’. Courts and tribunals
when acting in administrative capacity, fall under
the remit of the Charter.
Direct application of Charter rights to Courts in
their judicial capacity?
Section 6(2)(b) imposes obligations on courts
and tribunals to the ‘extent that they have
functions under Part 2 and Division 3 of Part 3’.
Part 2 lists the Charter rights, and Division 3 of
Part 3 covers the Court’s role in interpreting and
applying the Charter.
The Judicial College of Victoria has observed
that ‘the direct application of Charter rights to
courts and tribunals [in this section] appears
to contrast with ss 4 and 38, which state
that courts and tribunals are bound to act
compatibly with Charter rights only when acting
in an administrative capacity’.61
Section 6(2)(b) has been subject to extensive
interpretation, with the caselaw generally
adopting what is known as the ‘intermediate
construction’,62 which is that the ‘function’
referred to in the Charter is to enforce directly
on the courts ‘only those rights enacted in Part 2
that relate to court proceedings’.63 This involves
looking at the particular functions the court is
using in the proceeding and determining if it is
‘exercising functions involving the application
of human rights that relate to court or tribunal
proceedings’.64 As a result, ‘courts and tribunals
are directly bound to act compatibly with
Charter rights that relate to a court and tribunal
proceeding even when acting in a judicial
capacity’.65 In Secretary, Department of Human
Services v Sanding this was stated as follows:
The functions of courts and tribunals
under Pt 2 referred to in s 6(2)(b) are the
functions of applying and giving effect to
those human rights which relate to court
and tribunal proceedings. By excluding
courts and tribunals from the definition
of a public authority (except when acting
administratively), while at the same time
making the Charter apply directly to them
in respect of the specified functions, the
legislation has preserved the substantive
legal foundation of the jurisdiction of
courts and tribunals, while making it
obligatory for them to act compatibly with
the Charter in respect of those matters
which are within their own direct control,
including the conduct of proceedings in
accordance with the right to a fair hearing
under s 24(1) of the Charter.66
Nature of Cases where the Charter was
applied to Judicial Functions in accordance
with s 6(2)(b)
There are multiple cases where Charter rights
are applied to Courts due to lack of fair
proceedings in bail applications, criminal trials or
sentencing hearings,67 as well as child protection
and mental health proceedings.68
Example: Matsoukatidou v Yarra Ranges69
The Supreme Court of Victoria found that a
court or tribunal must assist a self-represented
party with a disability to effectively participate
in a hearing. The applicant had sought judicial
review in the County Court of a decision of the
local council about her home. The applicant
suffered from a learning disability. She
misunderstood the nature of the proceedings,
the applicable legal test, and was not given an
adequate opportunity to make her submissions.
As a result, her application was dismissed. On
appeal, the Supreme Court found that the right
to equality under the Charter applied to the
practice and procedure of courts, positively
obliging judges to make reasonable adjustments
and accommodations to ensure equal access to
justice. The case was sent back to the County
Court to be reheard.
FREE AND EQUAL A Human Rights Act for Australia 2022
153
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление