Chapter 6: Positive duty
6.1 Introduction
[I]t is in the area of administrative
compliance that the real success story
of human rights lies.1
A Human Rights Act would create a legislative
obligation for public authorities to act
compatibly with the human rights expressed in
the Human Rights Act and to consider human
rights when making decisions. This is also
known as a ‘positive duty’ applying to public
authorities. Compliance with this duty would be
judicially reviewable.
The positive duty is at the centre of the Human
Rights Act.
It builds on the developing understanding
of human rights over more than 10 years of
engagement in the Parliamentary scrutiny
process involving statements of compatibility
and review by the PJCHR. The integration of
human rights considerations into the processes
of public authorities should make officials
more aware of the impacts of their decisions,
and therefore help to prevent human rights
breaches.2 If the Human Rights Act is working
well, it has an upstream impact within the
day-to-day processes of government, and the
court has a less prominent role addressing
downstream breaches, through the possibility
of litigation.
The positive duty would support decision
makers to consider human rights in a way that
is more appropriate to individual circumstances,
rather than taking a blanket approach when
making a decision that affects a person’s rights
and freedoms. For example, when making
decisions about residential or disability care
placements, a public authority may need to
consider circumstances specific to the individual
– such as whether they would be able to
when making decisions about housing, whether
accommodations may be needed to realise
the individual’s right to privacy in accordance
with their particular circumstances.4 The proper
consideration of an individual’s human rights
in decision making would help make public
services more accessible and fairer for all.
When the Victorian Charter was being debated,
the Attorney-General explained the positive duty
provision as follows:
This is a key provision of the charter.
It seeks to ensure that human rights
are observed in administrative practice
and the development of policy within
the public sector without the need for
recourse to the courts. The experience
in other jurisdictions that have used
this model is that it is in the area of
administrative compliance that the real
success story of human rights lies. Many
public sector bodies that already deal with
difficult issues of balancing competing
rights and obligations in carrying out their
functions have welcomed the clarity and
authority that a human rights bill provides
in dealing with these issues. In conjunction
with the general law, the charter provides
a basic standard and a reference point for
discussion and development of policy and
practice in relation to these often sensitive
and complex issues.5
Free & Equal stakeholders confirmed that the
key success of state and territory human rights
instruments in their experience has been the
diversion or alteration of government policy as
a result of the procedures in place. This is also
reflected in reviews of the existing Human Rights
Acts at the state and territory reviews. For
example, the five year review of the ACT Human
Rights Act found that its
practise their religion in the care facility.3 Or
FREE AND EQUAL A Human Rights Act for Australia 2022
139
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление