The Commission’s additional proposal for a right
to a healthy environment provides that every
person has the right to an environment that
does not produce adverse health consequences.
This means that a person has the right not to
be subject to unlawful pollution of air water and
soil; and to access safe and uncontaminated
water and nutritionally safe food. The right also
prohibits discrimination in the enjoyment of
this right, and reflects the overarching ICESCR
obligation to prevent unjustified retrogressive
measures (meaning that there should be no
unjustified backward movement with respect to
the enjoyment of this right).
The Commission’s proposal for a right to a
healthy environment draws directly upon the
existing ICESCR obligations contained within
the right to health, the right to an adequate
standard of living (Articles 12, 11) as well as
the right to life in the ICCPR (Article 6). The
right to health includes obligations on states
to refrain from ‘unlawfully polluting air, water
and soil, for example, through industrial waste
from State-owned facilities’.72 The right to life
‘depends…on measures taken by States parties
to preserve the environment and protect it
against harm, pollution and climate change
caused by public and private actors’.73 The right
to health requires states to ‘ensure access to the
minimum essential food which is nutritionally
adequate and safe’ and to ‘an adequate supply
of safe and potable water’.74 The right to an
adequate standard of living also includes the
obligation to protect against the ‘contamination
of water supplies’.75 The proposal for the
right to a healthy environment is therefore a
thematic articulation of elements of existing
rights (that would also be implemented via the
Commission’s proposals).
The Commission’s decision to include an
environmental element reflects growing
international consensus and practice around
the role and importance of environmental
protections. In July 2022, the UN General
Assembly adopted a resolution to declare access
to a clean, healthy and sustainable environment,
to be a universal human right. There were 161
votes in favour, including Australia, and eight
abstentions.76 The resolution was based on
similar text adopted in 2021 by the Human
Rights Council.77 Currently, approximately
80% of UN member States recognise the right
to a healthy environment in constitutional or
legislative texts.78 There was support for the
inclusion of environmental considerations by a
number of Free & Equal stakeholders.79
Finally, it is crucial to recognise that ICESCR
implementation, particularly with regard
to progressive realisation, occurs primarily
outside of the courts. Progressive realisation
is most relevant to ‘upstream’ decision making
about policy and resourcing. In relation to
this process, the culture of the public sector,
external oversight measures and parliamentary
scrutiny mechanisms are key elements towards
ensuring compliance. These forums would
provide opportunities to address the progressive
realisation aspects of key rights, and are well
suited to addressing overarching, systemic
policy concerns. For example, the Commission
could have a role in reporting on the progressive
realisation of ICESCR rights. This would help to
ensure that progressive realisation remains part
of picture, even if it is not relevant to the work
of courts or with respect to the individual claims
made under the Human Rights Act.
FREE AND EQUAL A Human Rights Act for Australia 2022
131
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление