95
In New Zealand’s recent UPR, 36 recommendations were made in relation to
women, a number of which related to the gender pay gap. Although the Government
accepted these recommendations, the actions recorded in the NPA only commit to
monitoring the gender pay gap, not any measurable outcomes.
96
Both the HRA and the BORA recognise that to overcome discrimination, positive
actions may be needed to enable particular groups to achieve equal outcomes with
other groups in our society. ‘Special measures’ or ‘affirmative action’ are not
discriminatory if they assist people in certain groups to achieve equality where
information shows that the present position is unequal. The State Services
Commission support affirmative action with regard to achieving equal employment
opportunities.
97
In 2012 the Commission released its report Caring Counts Tautiaki tika which
inquired into equal employment issues in the aged care workforce.48 The report
found significant and enduring pay inequalities for aged care workers and made a
series of recommendations across a number of areas, including leadership, pay,
qualifications, transparency and fair travel policies.
98
In October 2014, the Court of Appeal issued a decision in TerraNova v Service and
Food Workers Union (SFWU) on the interpretation of the Equal Pay Act 1972 (“EPA”).
The Court of Appeal confirmed an earlier Employment Court decision that:
99
the EPA provides for equal pay for work of equal value (pay equity) meaning
women should receive the same pay as men for jobs that require similar skill,
effort and responsibility;
the Employment Court may look beyond the immediate employer or industry for
comparators if an appropriate comparator does not exist in the immediate
employer or industry; and
the Employment Court must take into account evidence of systemic
undervaluation of the work in question derived from current or historic or
structural gender discrimination.
In response to this case the Government has established two new processes:
the Government Joint working party on equal pay principles across the whole
workforce to develop a set of principles for implementation of equal pay in
female dominant work forces; and
a process to negotiate a settlement for care and support workers to try and
resolve the TerraNova case before it is due to return to court in March 2016.
48
http://old.hrc.co.nz/2012/05/27/caring-counts-report-says-sorting-caregivers%e2%80%99-wages-affordable-andnecessary/
Page 29 of 93
Human Rights Commission submission to the Human Rights Committee in relation to New Zealand’s 6th periodic review under the ICCPR