Part II Protecting and promoting the rights of women and girls: NHRIs in action
Ensuring gender expertise on the inquiry team: NHRIs should appoint Inquiry Commissioners
and staff with the necessary skills and experience to undertake the research, collect the evidence,
lead the public hearings, engage the media, analyse the evidence and draft the inquiry report and its
recommendations. All members of the inquiry team should have a strong understanding of the issue
being considered and the international legal framework around the human rights of women and girls.
The inquiry team should also include substantial gender expertise, preferably among all or most team
members. Attention to gender and the human rights of women should be a general responsibility, not
something that is designating to a single person as a “gender focal point” or “women’s rights expert”.
That approach can, in fact, risk marginalizing gender issues and compromising the outcome of the
inquiry. 108
NEW ZEALAND: INQUIRY INTO THE AGED CARE WORKFORCE
In 2011 and 2012 the New Zealand Human Rights Commission used its inquiry
powers to investigate equal employment opportunities in the aged care sector.
The inquiry was prompted by two concerns. One related to the low pay and
undervaluing of work in the aged care sector, where over 90 per cent of New
Zealand’s aged care workforce is female. The other related to the link between
the value that society places on the aged care workforce and the respect and
dignity of older people.
A marked feature of the inquiry was the high degree of participation by
stakeholders. Almost 900 people participated in the inquiry, including carers,
older people receiving care and their families, residential and home support
care providers, funders, politicians, unions and civil society.
A consensus emerged during the course of the inquiry that caring work was
extremely demanding and skilled work that was very poorly paid. A summit
was held to bring together stakeholder representatives to consider how
the recommendations could be implemented. The consensus about the
inadequacy of pay rates for workers in the aged care sector was transformed
into a shared commitment to address the issue.
A draft of the inquiry report was sent to all those who participated, with
feedback incorporated in the final version.108 The recommendations were
developed by the Equal Employment Opportunities Commissioner and the
inquiry team after the feedback process and then endorsed by the New
Zealand Human Rights Commission. The report also included the account of
the Equal Employment Opportunities Commissioner working “undercover”
in a rest home. This proved to be a compelling story and the report received
nation-wide media attention over an extended period.
108
The inquiry report – Caring Counts: Report of the Inquiry into the Aged Care Workforce – is available at www.neon.org.nz/
agedcareinquiry/.
Chapter 6: Conducting inquiries into systemic violations of women’s and girls’ human rights | 73