Chapter 3 - Report of the Research and Policy Development Group
7. JUDICIAL DECISIONS
(a) Penalty for Statutory Rape
On 27 August, the Court of Appeal upheld the decision of a Sessions Court to impose a five-year
good behaviour bond instead of a custodial sentence on a national sportsman charged with
the rape of a 13-year-old girl. In so deciding, the Sessions Court judge took into consideration
that the girl had consented to the act. The Court of Appeal was of the opinion that the accused,
aged 21, had not tricked the girl into submitting to him and that no violence was involved. In
addition, the three-member bench ruled that the public interest would not be served in jailing
the accused as he “has a bright future” in sports.
On 28 August, in a similar case in Penang, the Sessions Court imposed a RM25,000 good
behaviour bond of three years on an electrician convicted of raping his then 12-year-old girlfriend.
The court was of the opinion that the sexual act was consensual, and that the accused had not
tricked the girl into the act. However, on 19 November, the High Court of Penang overturned the
decision on appeal and the offender was sentenced instead to five and a half years’ jail.
Based on the two reported cases, the Commission expressed its concern over the lenient
sentences meted out on two offenders guilty of statutory rape. Such sentences might send the
wrong message to would-be offenders, and thus would not serve as effective deterrence. The
Commission was also concerned that consent on the part of the child victims in both cases was
considered as mitigating factors. That consent of a child should not be a mitigating factor in
such cases is underscored by the legal prohibition of sexual relations with a female child under
the age of 16, regardless of consent on her part. Clearly, Malaysia’s penal laws recognise that
a child may lack the necessary maturity to give real consent or may be unduly influenced into
giving apparent consent.
The Commission also took a serious view of public disclosure of the offender’s name in each
case, which may lead to the victim’s identity being exposed. The CRC stipulates that by reason of
their physical and mental immaturity, children are entitled to special safeguards and care, which
include legal protection. The best interests of the child in such cases, including the protection
of the victim’s identity, her safety and well-being, should have been of paramount concern as
enshrined in Articles 19 and 34 of the CRC.
(b) Cross-dressing
On 11 October, the High Court of Seremban dismissed an application by Muhammad Juzaili
Mohd Khamis and three others for a declaration that Section 66 of the Syariah Criminal (Negeri
Sembilan) Enactment 1992 (Enactment 4 of 1992) – which criminalises any male person who
‘wears woman’s attire’ or ‘poses as a woman’ – is inconsistent with fundamental liberties
guaranteed by the Federal Constitution; namely, the prohibition of discrimination based on
gender, freedom of expression, freedom of movement, and the rights to live with dignity and
privacy, and to livelihood. According to media reports, the High Court ruled that the Enactment
excludes the fundamental liberties under the Federal Constitution.
109
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление