Chapter 3 - Report of the Research and Policy Development Group
Many Islamic scholars agree that the prescribed penalties cannot be established by a solitary
Hadith (ahad), and that unbelief by itself does not call for the death penalty. The key factor which
determines the application of this punishment is aggression and hostility to believers and the
need to prevent possible sedition (fitnah) against the religion and state.
In addition, the death penalty in the Hadith is not designed for apostasy per se but for high
treason (hirabah) – when apostasy is accompanied by hostility and rebellion against the
community and its legitimate leadership. The Hadith is a general (‘amm) command which is in
need of specification (takhsis).
(c) Women’s Participation in Government
Women’s participation in government should be equal at all levels with the exception perhaps
of cases where equality may not be advisable such as in performing police and military duties.
The only exception of Syariah with regard to women’s participation in government concerns
the position of the head of state based on a presumptive consensus (ijma’). However, there
is no clear authority in the sources to prevent equality even at this level. The prevalence of
constitutional checks and balances and separation of power in modern constitutions, have
altogether altered the material attributes of leadership. The rules of Islamic jurisprudence also
hold that a substantial change in the effective cause and rationale (illah) of a ruling should be
followed by a corresponding change and suitable ruling through ijtihad (to derive and deduce
religious opinion about a matter that is not mentioned in the sources of Islam).
(d) Syariah Law of Inheritance
The argument cited in support of larger share of inheritance for men is that a man is responsible
for the maintenance of a woman’s needs in marriage, as well as for remedial financial provisions
to help divorced women.
It was suggested that jurists and judges should explore the principle of juristic preference
(istihsan) which could address existing laws that lead to unfair results. Istihsan authorises the
jurist and judge to find an alternative and a preferable solution to the case before them, which
would realise considerations of equity and fairness. However, jurists and judges have not made
effective use of istihsan, which does not seek to introduce a new law but to address situations
case by case when strict implementation of the law could lead to unfair result.
The RTD concluded with agreement that most principles of human rights in the UDHR are
consistent with the Syariah except for certain issues such as the rights of the Lesbian, Gay,
Bisexual and Transgender community, gender equality, and same-sex marriage.
108
Выберите целевой абзац3
Подключиться к абзацу
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Добавить в оглавление