wages in the construction industry. It is also highly probable that it will lead to the
recurrence of illegal multilayered subcontracting problem and the rampant overdue wages
problems affecting unregistered builders in the intermediate tiers. As it was deemed too
difficult to control illegal multilayered subcontracting practices exceeding the minimum
numbers of subcontracting, as long as subcontracting by unregistered builders was
permitted, the Commission expressed its opinion that such an amendment was detrimental
because the bill would not only fail to meet the purpose of protecting working conditions
of daily construction workers and their basic labor rights, but also significantly undermine
the sound development of construction industry.
4) Reply to Inquiry on a Measure to Include Exemption of Military Service in the
Certificates of Military Service
Concerning measures to record and issue past violation record of the Military Service
Act on the certificate of military service to prevent crimes of avoiding military service, the
Military Manpower Administration submitted an inquiry to the Commission on whether
such measure would violate human rights.
On March 25, 2010, the Commission responded to the inquiry by stating that the issue
of avoidance of military service should be addressed through multi-faceted fundamental
approaches,
including
military
service-related
administration,
military
service
environment, and compensation for carrying out military service and that adopting such
measures is deemed undesirable as recording and issuing past criminal records of violating
Military Service Act on the certificate of military service may infringe upon privacy rights.
5) Opinion on the Partial Amendment to the Passport Act
On April 8, 2010, the Commission delivered to the Minister for Foreign Affairs and
Trade its opinion on a partial amendment to the Article 6(2)5 of Enforcement Decree of
Passport Act, which restricted the passport validity period to less than five years for those
34
Part II. Major Activities of the Commission