6
H U M A N R I G H T S COMMISSION | A FAIR GO FOR ALL?
Resistance to special measures is related to a partial
understanding of equality. Many New Zealanders recognise
formal equality or “equality before the law”. This means,
for example, that everyone has the same legal right to
attend school or receive medical care, or be treated fairly
in the justice system. In practice, however, not everyone
is able to access education, health or justice services in
the same way due to a various socio-economic obstacles,
including discrimination.
Substantive equality is concerned with ensuring that
everyone can in fact compete on an equal basis;
it highlights socio-economic obstacles (including
discrimination) that may impede equality of opportunity.24
The Western Australian Equal Opportunity Commission
summarises the distinction between formal and substantive
equality:
If you want to treat me equally, you
may have to be prepared to treat me
differently.25
It is important to note a distinction between special
measures – which are temporary, until such time as the
inequality is removed – and permanent rights. Special
measures to ensure equality contribute to, but are not a
substitute for, programmes for all New Zealanders designed
to ensure access to decent work, healthy affordable
housing, and effective delivery of health, education and
other services. Special measures are just one way of
ensuring equality of outcomes for the diverse groups that
make up New Zealand society.26