Australian Human Rights Commission
Submission to UN Committee Against Torture, 17 October 2014
•
•
•
retain that information to the extent necessary to make decisions in the
course of the proceedings;
use or weigh that information as part of the process of making
decisions; and
communicate decisions in some way.
68.
The final report of the inquiry will be released shortly.
69.
All Australian jurisdictions have enacted legislation dealing with fitness to
stand trial. However, the legislation is considered to be complex and in some
respects, ambiguous.49 The disparity between the legislation of the various
states and territories adds further complications. It has been argued that a
more streamlined and consistent approach to determining an accused's fitness
to plead or stand trial would improve access to justice for people with
disabilities, particularly people with intellectual disabilities, whose fitness to
plead is likely to be an issue in criminal proceedings.50
Juvenile justice
(a)
Detention rates
70.
The Commission remains concerned about rates of young people in detention.
In 2012-13, there were 774 children aged 10-17 years in corrective detention
on an average day in Australia.51 There is a particularly high number of
children in detention in the Northern Territory and Western Australia compared
to other states and territories.52
71.
In 2011 the House of Representatives Standing Committee on Aboriginal and
Torres Strait Islander Affairs report Doing Time, Time for Doing: Indigenous
youth in the criminal justice system,53 found that ‘the overrepresentation of
Indigenous juveniles and young adults’ has worsened over the last 20 years.54
72.
The National Children’s Commissioner has made a number of
recommendations in her first Children’s Rights Report to Parliament,55
including that Australia consider raising the minimum age of criminal
responsibility to an internationally acceptable level, remove children who are
17 years old from the adult justice system in Queensland, and establish a
mechanism for investigating abuse at youth detention centres.
(b)
Separate custodial sites for children and young people
73.
The Commission has expressed concern that all child offenders are still not
held in separate correctional centres from adults.56
74.
In 2013 the Commission intervened in proceedings in the Supreme Court of
Western Australia to provide information on minimum standards in juvenile
detention. The matter was a challenge of decisions to declare two units of an
adult prison, Hakea Prison, as a juvenile detention centre and to transfer
children to Hakea Prison from Banksia Hill Detention Centre. 57 In its
submissions to the court, the Commission outlined specific areas of concern
for children transferred to Hakea Prison. In particular, the Commission was
18