First Nations Consultations For the Australian Human Rights Commission
4.1.2 Western legal system
Systemic racism is a pervasive experience described by First Nations people in contact with
Australian criminal legal systems. It is connected to a severe and widespread lack of
comprehension of the intergenerational impacts of colonisation, trauma, grief and loss, and a lack
of resourcing and support for community-led and culturally safe services.
A crucial factor in the success of anti-racism initiatives is recognising the cultural disconnect
between the Western-designed legal system and First Nations ways of knowing, being and doing.
This disconnect prioritises the dominant culture and creates barriers to fair and equitable
outcomes for First Nations people. Cultural ways of knowing, being and doing should be
acknowledged and embedded to remove barriers and improve outcomes. Some of the key areas
of disconnect highlighted by participants included the lack of recognition and acceptance of
complex kinship systems. This disconnect especially impacts on experiences of communication
and information sharing, particularly when related to privacy and confidentiality.
Australia's legal system aspires to be neutral and objective, yet concepts of race have profoundly
shaped both the laws themselves and how courts interpret them. This was reported on by many
people who were consulted throughout the in-person community and service provider
consultations as one of the greatest challenges for anti-racism strategies.
4.1.3 Sector and service delivery context
Racism is deeply embedded in the policies and practices of institutions, making it impossible to
address through individual efforts alone. Systemic changes are imperative to dismantle these
deeply ingrained biases.
Sector based consultations identified the unique and specific ways in which systemic racism is
evidenced throughout the education, health and justice sectors at a service delivery level. This
context is important to consider in the development of anti-racism initiatives to determine
transferability and measurability.
Education Sector:
In the realm of education, systemic racism is evident through the exclusion of First
Nations perspectives in the curriculum, biased disciplinary actions against First Nations
students, and the underrepresentation of First Nations staff. Participants noted that First
Nations history is frequently overlooked or misrepresented in school curriculums,
perpetuating ignorance and prejudice. There was a strong advocacy for comprehensive
curriculum reform to inclusively integrate First Nations voices and histories. Curriculum
reform, hiring practices, and disciplinary policies require comprehensive overhauls to
foster a more inclusive and supportive environment for First Nations students and staff.
Systemic reforms must include First Nations voices in decision-making processes at all
levels, ensuring that policies and practices genuinely reflect the needs and perspectives
of First Nations communities. This includes integrating First Nations history, culture, and
knowledge into the curriculum, and actively recruiting and retaining First Nations
educators and administrators.
An Anti-Racism Framework: Voices of First Nations Peoples
Page 45